N'Kontchou Gisele, Nault Jean-Charles, Sutter Olivier, Bourcier Valerie, Coderc Emmanuelle, Grando Veronique, Nahon Pierre, Ganne-Carrié Nathalie, Diallo Abou, Sellier Nicolas, Seror Olivier
Service d'Hépatologie de l'Hôpital Jean Verdier, Hôpitaux Universitaires Paris-Seine-Saint-Denis, Assistance Publique Hôpitaux de Paris, Bondy, France.
Unité de Formation et de Recherche Santé Médecine et Biologie Humaine, Université Paris 13, Communauté d'Universités et Etablissements Sorbonne Paris Cité, Paris, France.
Liver Cancer. 2019 May;8(3):172-185. doi: 10.1159/000489319. Epub 2018 Jun 28.
Only few patients with cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) larger than 5 cm are amenable to resection or straight liver transplantation, and in such circumstances, multibipolar radiofrequency ablation (mbp-RFA) could be a reliable alternative. This study was aimed to assess the long-term outcome in patients treated with mbp-RFA for unresectable HCC > 5 cm.
Eighty-three consecutive patients with cirrhosis (median age 70 years [37-93 years], 67 males, BCLC A/B/C: 54/21/8, 74 naive) with up to three HCCs, the largest > 5 cm in diameter (median: 6.2 cm, 5.1-9 cm, 22 infiltrative forms, 12 with segmental portal invasion of which 10 were infiltrative forms) were treated with mbp-RFA. Overall (OS) and recurrence-free (RFS) survival and their associated predictive factors were assessed.
Complete ablation was observed in 78/83 (94%) patients. Thirty-one side effects occurred, including 6 (7%) severe complications. After a median follow-up of 26.1 months (1-112 months), in naive patients the 3- and 5-year OS was 51% (38-62) and 24% (13-36), 63 and 30% for mass-forming and 25 and 6% for infiltrative form, respectively. Infiltrative form (HR: 2.5 [1.33-4.69], = 0.004) was the only independent OS predictor. In naive patients with mass-forming and infiltrative form, the 3- and 5-year RFS were 47 and 17 and 18 and 18%, respectively. Alpha-fetoprotein (HR: 2.86 [1.32-6.21], = 0.008), multinodular form (HR: 2.74 [1.4-5.38], = 0.003) and infiltrative form (HR: 3.43 [1.67-7.01], = 0.0007) were independent RFS predictors.
mbp-RFA offers good OS in inoperable patients with cirrhosis and large HCC, with acceptable safety profile. For infiltrative forms, although mbp-RFA leads to complete responses in more than 80% cases, few only remain tumor progression-free in long-term.
仅有少数肝硬化且肝细胞癌(HCC)直径大于5 cm的患者适合进行切除术或直接肝移植,在这种情况下,多极射频消融术(mbp-RFA)可能是一种可靠的替代方法。本研究旨在评估接受mbp-RFA治疗的直径大于5 cm不可切除HCC患者的长期结局。
连续纳入83例肝硬化患者(中位年龄70岁[37 - 93岁],男性67例,BCLC A/B/C期:54/21/8,74例初治患者),最多有3个HCC,最大直径>5 cm(中位值:6.2 cm,5.1 - 9 cm,22例浸润型,12例伴有门静脉分支侵犯,其中10例为浸润型),接受mbp-RFA治疗。评估总生存期(OS)、无复发生存期(RFS)及其相关预测因素。
83例患者中有78例(94%)观察到完全消融。发生31例副作用,包括6例(7%)严重并发症。中位随访26.1个月(1 - 112个月)后,初治患者的3年和5年OS分别为51%(38 - 62)和24%(13 - 36),肿块型分别为63%和30%,浸润型分别为25%和6%。浸润型(HR:2.5[1.33 - 4.69],P = 0.004)是唯一的独立OS预测因素。在初治的肿块型和浸润型患者中,3年和5年RFS分别为47%和17%以及18%和18%。甲胎蛋白(HR:2.86[1.32 - 6.21],P = 0.008)、多结节型(HR:2.74[1.4 - 5.38],P = 0.003)和浸润型(HR:3.43[1.67 - 7.01],P = 0.0007)是独立的RFS预测因素。
mbp-RFA为无法手术的肝硬化和大HCC患者提供了良好的总生存期,安全性可接受。对于浸润型,尽管mbp-RFA在超过80%的病例中可导致完全缓解,但长期仅有少数患者无肿瘤进展。