School of Education and Psychology, University of Jinan, Jinan, China.
Psych J. 2020 Aug;9(4):472-489. doi: 10.1002/pchj.309. Epub 2019 Jul 11.
People attend to the same event or object by using a global or local processing style across different environments. Different physical environmental conditions, such as orderliness and disorderliness, activate different psychological states and produce different kinds of outcomes. However, previous work has rarely examined whether individuals exposed to different orderly or disorderly environments attend to the "global" or the "local" differently. Thus, in the current study, we conducted three behavioral experiments to directly examine the impact of disorder versus order cues on people's types of perceptual and conceptual processing (global vs. local). We asked participants to perform a typical Kimchi-Palmer figures task or a categorization task: with pre-primed disorderly or orderly physical environmental pictures (Experiment 1), with basic visual pictures (Experiment 2), and imagining a real environment (Experiment 3). The results revealed that in any of the above operations, orderly experience led to global perceptual processing, whereas disorderly experience led to local perceptual processing. This difference in processing style was not influenced by the participants' daily habits or their preference for the need for structure. However, this difference in perceptual processing style did not spill over to the conceptual processing style. These findings provide direct evidence of the effects of disorderliness versus orderliness on global versus local perceptual and conceptual processing and imply that environmental orderliness or disorderliness may functionally affect cognitive processing (i.e., how we see and think about events and objects). Thus, the findings creatively bridge several lines of research and shed light on a basic cognitive mechanism responsible for perceptions of order/disorder.
人们在不同的环境中通过使用全局或局部处理风格来关注同一个事件或对象。不同的物理环境条件,如有序和无序,会激活不同的心理状态并产生不同的结果。然而,之前的工作很少研究个体在不同的有序或无序环境中是否会以不同的方式关注“全局”或“局部”。因此,在当前的研究中,我们进行了三项行为实验,直接检验无序与有序线索对人们感知和概念处理类型(全局与局部)的影响。我们要求参与者执行典型的 Kimchi-Palmer 图形任务或分类任务:在有预呈现的无序或有序的物理环境图片的情况下(实验 1),在有基本视觉图片的情况下(实验 2),以及在想象真实环境的情况下(实验 3)。结果表明,在上述任何一种操作中,有序的体验都导致了全局的感知处理,而无序的体验则导致了局部的感知处理。这种处理风格的差异不受参与者的日常习惯或对结构需求的偏好的影响。然而,这种感知处理风格的差异并没有扩展到概念处理风格。这些发现为无序与有序对全局与局部感知和概念处理的影响提供了直接证据,并暗示环境的有序性或无序性可能会对认知处理(即我们如何看待和思考事件和对象)产生功能影响。因此,这些发现创造性地弥合了几条研究线,并为负责感知秩序/无序的基本认知机制提供了启示。