Gondo Tendayi
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, School of Environmental Sciences, University of Venda, Thohoyandou, South Africa.
Jamba. 2019 Jul 5;11(2):716. doi: 10.4102/jamba.v11i2.716. eCollection 2019.
Many interventions were sought in the past to address the human health and aquatic life implications associated with poor Municipal Solid Waste Management (MSWM) practices. Majority of such interventions failed to recognise that such human health risks and threats to aquatic life are to a large extent moderated by unique characteristics of different urban and rural spaces where such waste is generated. They failed to employ multiple criteria-based evaluation models that are appropriate in depicting the complex and often interrelated criteria inherently associated with MSWM. This study used the Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) to evaluate several interdependent variables that define human health and aquatic life hazards associated with poor MSWM practices. Specifically, HCA was used to identify relative similarities among, and distances between a sample of 26 Ethiopian cities and towns in terms of MSWM health threats. Results indicated that threats to human health and aquatic life are surmountable for cities whose economies are relatively low and lacking capacity in terms of SWM infrastructure, acceptable institutional arrangements and better health-care facilities to deal with associated SWM-induced human health risks. Risk of flood waters owing to low altitude has also compounded the urban health conditions in such cities. Despite being better positioned, the analysis observed that some bigger cities still face problems in terms of effective land use planning policies, commitment towards implementing effective SWM programmes as well as the absence of water safety management plans. It concluded by proposing a number of targeted interventions seeking to improve the human health conditions of cities failing to cope with uncollected waste.
过去人们寻求了许多干预措施来解决与不良城市固体废弃物管理(MSWM)做法相关的人类健康和水生生物问题。此类干预措施大多未能认识到,此类对人类健康的风险和对水生生物的威胁在很大程度上受到产生此类废弃物的不同城乡空间独特特征的调节。它们未能采用基于多标准的评估模型,而这些模型适用于描述与城市固体废弃物管理内在相关的复杂且往往相互关联的标准。本研究使用层次聚类分析(HCA)来评估几个相互依存的变量,这些变量定义了与不良城市固体废弃物管理做法相关的人类健康和水生生物危害。具体而言,层次聚类分析用于确定26个埃塞俄比亚城镇样本在城市固体废弃物管理健康威胁方面的相对相似性和距离。结果表明,对于那些经济相对较低、在固体废弃物管理基础设施、可接受的制度安排以及应对相关城市固体废弃物管理引发的人类健康风险的更好医疗设施方面缺乏能力的城市,对人类健康和水生生物的威胁是可以克服的。低海拔导致的洪水风险也加剧了这些城市的健康状况。尽管条件较好,但分析发现,一些大城市在有效的土地利用规划政策、实施有效城市固体废弃物管理计划的承诺以及缺乏水安全管理计划方面仍然面临问题。研究最后提出了一些有针对性的干预措施,旨在改善那些无法应对未收集废弃物的城市的人类健康状况。