Virginia Tech, School of Education, Blacksburg, Virginia.
Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2021 Jan;1483(1):19-35. doi: 10.1111/nyas.14176. Epub 2019 Jul 16.
This literature review of contemporary mentoring delineates mentoring definitions and anchors these with explanatory discourse. Select empirical studies spanning 1983-2019 were analyzed, with a focus on education across grade levels. Alternative mentoring issues, types, and applications, also located, are integral to this discussion. While researchers describe what mentoring is, it is also important to clarify what it is not. Traditional definitions of mentoring have been losing traction, with mentoring alternatives forging new possibilities within changing learning and work environments. Contexts of mentoring include a personal-professional relationship to an educational process; an organizational, cultural, and global context; and a systemic reform strategy that builds human capacity. This complex definitional terrain is situated within theoretical mentoring frameworks. Mentoring as deep, equitable learning with social transformative value is illustrated. Science, technology, engineering, and mathematics and other educational examples serve this purpose. Challenges to the field from alternative mentoring theory are discussed for transparency around meanings of mentoring and contributions that advance socially just relationships, organizations, and cultures. The article provides a timely and needed framework to discriminate and differentiate mentoring from other developmental relationships.
这篇当代指导的文献综述阐述了指导的定义,并以解释性话语为这些定义提供了依据。分析了跨越 1983 年至 2019 年的 19 项实证研究,重点关注各级教育。此外,还找到了其他替代指导问题、类型和应用,这些都是本次讨论的重要组成部分。虽然研究人员描述了什么是指导,但澄清它不是什么也很重要。传统的指导定义已经失去了吸引力,而替代指导在不断变化的学习和工作环境中为新的可能性开辟了道路。指导的背景包括个人-专业关系到教育过程;组织、文化和全球背景;以及构建人力的系统改革战略。这种复杂的定义领域位于理论指导框架内。具有社会变革价值的深入、公平的学习被认为是指导。科学、技术、工程和数学以及其他教育实例为此服务。为了提高指导的透明度,并为促进公正的社会关系、组织和文化做出贡献,从替代指导理论的角度讨论了该领域的挑战。本文提供了一个及时且必要的框架,以区分指导与其他发展关系。