Sandrone Stefano
Department of Brain Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Med Educ Online. 2025 Dec;30(1):2509554. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2025.2509554. Epub 2025 May 25.
The Nobel Prize is one of the most coveted awards in the world. The Nobel winners, also called Laureates, are invited to Stockholm to deliver their Nobel Lecture. Typically, this includes a historical and scientific overview of their discoveries, often enriched by anecdotes from their personal and professional lives. In this study, we explored more than two hundred Nobel Lectures to examine whether, how and whom newly crowned Nobel Prize winners explicitly mentioned as their mentors. We conducted an exploratory analysis of 208 Nobel Lectures in Physiology or Medicine delivered between 1901 and 2023 by using the search function to look for the keyword . Only twenty Nobel Laureates have explicitly acknowledged their mentors in their Nobel Lectures. This recognition, which first occurred 73 years after the award's establishment, is more common among women, who are disproportionately underrepresented among awardees and often cited their postdoctoral advisors as mentors. The lack of overt recognition is surprising, especially considering the crucial role of mentorship in science, its broad societal value and the non-random patterns of Nobel mentoring relationships, where winners tend to have more Laureate ancestors, descendants and mentees. The word appears more frequently in the Lasker Awards, although these were launched only in 1945 and feature brief 'Acceptance Remarks'. Even Oscar speeches, introduced nearly 30 years after the Nobel Prize and typically lasting less than a minute, mention mentors more frequently than Nobel Lectures do. This highlights an unexpected gap in the explicit acknowledgment of mentors in the context of the Nobel Prize, which we report and discuss for the first time.
诺贝尔奖是世界上最令人向往的奖项之一。诺贝尔奖得主,也被称为 laureates,会被邀请到斯德哥尔摩发表诺贝尔演讲。通常,这包括对他们的发现进行历史和科学概述,往往还会穿插他们个人和职业生涯中的轶事。在这项研究中,我们探究了两百多篇诺贝尔演讲,以考察新晋诺贝尔奖得主是否、如何以及明确提及了哪些人作为他们的导师。我们对1901年至2023年间发表的208篇生理学或医学领域的诺贝尔演讲进行了探索性分析,使用搜索功能查找关键词。只有二十位诺贝尔奖得主在他们的诺贝尔演讲中明确承认了他们的导师。这种认可在该奖项设立73年后才首次出现,在女性中更为常见,而女性在获奖者中所占比例严重偏低,她们经常将博士后导师作为导师提及。缺乏公开认可是令人惊讶的,尤其是考虑到导师在科学中的关键作用、其广泛的社会价值以及诺贝尔导师关系的非随机模式,即获奖者往往有更多的诺贝尔奖得主祖先、后代和学生。“导师”这个词在拉斯克奖中出现得更频繁,尽管拉斯克奖直到1945年才设立,且只有简短的“获奖感言”。甚至奥斯卡颁奖典礼的演讲,比诺贝尔奖晚推出近30年,通常持续不到一分钟,却比诺贝尔演讲更频繁地提到导师。这凸显了诺贝尔奖背景下在明确承认导师方面存在的意外差距,我们首次对此进行了报道和讨论。