Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC, 27101, USA.
Department of Neurology, Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center, 1 Medical Center Blvd, Winston-Salem, NC, 27101, USA.
Neurocrit Care. 2019 Dec;31(3):550-558. doi: 10.1007/s12028-019-00779-4.
Spinal procedures such as lumbar punctures (LPs), epidurals, and spinal blocks are essential components to clinical practice but are challenging to teach, learn, or practice on real patients due to patient safety and comfort limiting the number of attempts. Resident physicians traditionally learn these spinal procedural skills through observation of a more senior physician before attempting the procedure. Simulation using models can improve providers' competency without introducing an added risk to patients. A difficulty encountered with access to simulation training for such procedures is the limited availability of simulators. While there are several high-quality, commercially available models that mimic the anatomy of lumbar spine, the cost of these models often limits the access to students and practitioners. The other challenge is access to simulators with versatility that can be used for palpation as well as ultrasound (US)-guided procedures. A simulator that can combine practice of both palpation and US-guided modalities would be efficacious in reducing cost to the teaching institutions. We attempted to overcome the access barrier to spinal models by developing an alternative that provides a good simulator for both palpation and US-guided LP while keeping the cost low. Our model can be easily manufactured by not only clinicians but also medical students.
A literature review was conducted to assess the available research and information on the production and use of simulators for practicing LPs and other spinal procedures. Publications queried described the production of models and utilizing the information compiled we devised and fabricated a model.
A lumbar spine model was developed using computed tomography spine data of an average-sized male patient without lumbar spine pathology. The model was created using medical imaging processing software and printed on 3D printer using nylon plastic. This model was then utilized by residents, advanced practice providers, and medical students for palpation and US-guided LP simulation training.
An inexpensive reusable non-commercial LP simulator can be an effective method for teaching invasive procedures like LPs, especially if it can be used both for palpation and US-guided procedures. The method outlined here can be easily reproduced in a relatively short amount of time. We recognize one limitation in the widespread dissemination of this technique being access to a 3D printer and digital designs for printing. Future studies will be necessary to determine the efficacy of the homemade LP simulator in teaching neurointensivist in training.
腰椎穿刺(LP)、硬膜外和脊椎阻滞等脊椎程序是临床实践的重要组成部分,但由于患者安全和舒适度限制了尝试次数,因此难以教授、学习或在真实患者身上进行实践。住院医师传统上通过观察更高级别的医师来学习这些脊椎程序技能,然后再尝试进行该程序。使用模型进行模拟可以在不增加患者风险的情况下提高提供者的能力。然而,获得此类程序模拟培训的一个困难是模拟设备的可用性有限。虽然有几种高质量的商用模型可以模拟腰椎的解剖结构,但这些模型的成本往往限制了学生和从业者的使用。另一个挑战是获得具有多功能性的模拟器,既可以用于触诊,也可以用于超声(US)引导的程序。一种可以将触诊和 US 引导模式的练习结合起来的模拟器,将有助于降低教学机构的成本。我们试图通过开发一种替代方案来克服脊椎模型的访问障碍,该方案为触诊和 US 引导 LP 提供了一种良好的模拟器,同时保持低成本。我们的模型不仅可以由临床医生,还可以由医学生轻松制造。
进行了文献综述,以评估有关 LP 和其他脊椎程序模拟设备的生产和使用的现有研究和信息。查询的出版物描述了模型的生产,并利用汇编的信息,我们设计并制造了一个模型。
使用平均体型男性患者的计算机断层扫描脊椎数据开发了一个腰椎模型,该患者没有腰椎病变。该模型是使用医学成像处理软件创建的,并使用尼龙塑料在 3D 打印机上打印。然后,居民、高级执业医师和医学生使用该模型进行触诊和 US 引导 LP 模拟培训。
一种廉价、可重复使用的非商业性 LP 模拟器可以是一种教授侵入性程序(如 LP)的有效方法,特别是如果它既可以用于触诊,也可以用于 US 引导的程序。这里概述的方法可以在相对较短的时间内轻松复制。我们认识到,这种技术在广泛传播方面的一个限制是 3D 打印机和打印数字设计的获取。未来的研究将有必要确定自制 LP 模拟器在培训神经介入医师中的教学效果。