Department of Anesthesiology and Reanimation, Faculty of Medicine, Hitit University, Çorum, Turkey.
Department of Anesthesiology and Reanimation, Erol Olçok Training and Research Hospital, Hitit University, Çorum, Turkey.
J Relig Health. 2020 Feb;59(1):96-112. doi: 10.1007/s10943-019-00886-8.
In 1950s, the concept of brain death, which began to be discussed primarily in terms of medicine and then in terms of religion, law, and ethics, became a central topic in all world countries as it was an early diagnosis of death. Despite the fact that brain death (BD) diagnosis is of importance for benefitting from organ and tissue transplantation of patients in the world, the literature still involves no bibliometric studies that made a holistic evaluation of the publications about this issue. The present study aims to investigate the top-cited articles about BD published between 1980 and 2018, identify the citation collaboration of the journals, demonstrate the collaboration between the countries, define the relationship between organ transplantation and BD, and reveal the latest developments and trend topics about this issue. In addition, this study aims to investigate the relationship between religions of countries and brain death publication productivity. Documents for bibliometric analysis were downloaded from Web of Science. The literature search was performed using the keywords "brain death/dead" during 1980-2018. The correlations between gross domestic product (GDP), Human Development Index (HDI) and publication productivity of the countries on BD were investigated with Spearman's correlation coefficient. There was a high-level, statistically significant correlation between the number of publications and GDP, and HDI and the number of publications about BD (r = 0.761, p < 0.001; r = 0.703, p < 0.001). The USA was the top country in terms of publication productivity, which was followed by developed countries such as Germany, Japan, France, and Spain. However, the contribution of the undeveloped or developing countries such as China, Brazil, Turkey, Iran, and South Africa was found to be considerably important. While many people in the world die with undamaged organs, many other people die needing those organs. Therefore, it is considered that the collaborations and thus multidisciplinary studies about BD should be increased in the world countries, and the countries should be involved in bigger collaborations instead of little clusters. Especially, Muslim countries should be encouraged to do research and publish studies about the issues of brain death and organ transplantation.
在上世纪 50 年代,脑死亡的概念开始主要在医学领域讨论,然后在宗教、法律和伦理领域讨论,成为所有世界国家的一个核心话题,因为它是早期死亡的诊断。尽管脑死亡 (BD) 诊断对于从患者的器官和组织移植中获益很重要,但文献中仍然没有对这一问题的出版物进行综合评估的文献计量学研究。本研究旨在调查 1980 年至 2018 年间发表的关于 BD 的高被引文章,确定期刊的引文合作情况,展示国家之间的合作情况,定义器官移植与 BD 的关系,并揭示该问题的最新发展和趋势话题。此外,本研究旨在调查国家宗教与脑死亡出版物生产力之间的关系。文献计量分析的文件从 Web of Science 下载。使用关键字“brain death/dead”在 1980-2018 年进行文献检索。用 Spearman 相关系数调查了国家的国内生产总值 (GDP)、人类发展指数 (HDI) 和 BD 出版物生产力之间的相关性。出版物数量与 GDP 之间存在高度显著的正相关,与 HDI 之间也存在正相关(r=0.761,p<0.001;r=0.703,p<0.001)。就出版物生产力而言,美国是排名最高的国家,其次是德国、日本、法国和西班牙等发达国家。然而,中国、巴西、土耳其、伊朗和南非等不发达国家或发展中国家的贡献被认为是相当重要的。虽然世界上有许多人去世时器官完好无损,但也有许多人去世时需要这些器官。因此,人们认为世界各国应增加对 BD 的合作和多学科研究,各国应参与更大的合作,而不是小的集群。特别是,应该鼓励穆斯林国家开展关于脑死亡和器官移植问题的研究和发表研究。