Identifying performance benchmarks and determinants for reproductive performance and calf survival using a longitudinal field study of cow-calf herds in western Canada.

The cow-calf industry in North America is in a period of rapid consolidation with corresponding increases in herd sizes and changes in management. The objectives of this study were to examine longitudinal data on reproductive performance in cow-calf herds and identify benchmarks for the most critical measures and important sources of differences among herds. To address these questions, a surveillance network was established in western Canada to collect data between 2013 to 2017 privately owned cow-calf herds during calving (n = 105 herds) and at pregnancy testing (n = 94 herds). Data were summarized for a number of indices of herd performance. However, the values considered to be most reliable and accurate were the percentage of females not pregnant when tested by a veterinarian, the percentage of calves dead within 24 hours of birth, and the percentage of calves dead from 24 hours to weaning. The mean and variation between herds for heifers, measured using standard deviation, was greater than for cows for: non-pregnancy (cows 6.8% (mean)±3.4%(SD), heifers 9.7%±8.2%), calf death from birth to 24 hours (cows 2.1%±1.6%, heifers 3.6%±4.5%), and calf death from 24 hours to weaning (cows 2.5%±2.4%, heifers 2.9%±3.9%). Benchmarks or performance targets derived from the 25th percentiles of these data for both cows and heifers were <5% for non-pregnancy risk and <1% for calf loss within 24 hours of birth. The suggested benchmark for calf loss from 24 hours to weaning was <2% for cows and <1% for heifers. All outcomes consistently displayed greater variation between herds as compared to year to year differences within herds with the exception of calf loss before 24 hours in cows. The timing of the start of breeding season was a consistent source of variation in risks of non-pregnancy and calf losses. Cows bred in April or earlier to start calving in late December or January were at increased risk of low pregnancy percentages (p<0.001) and calf losses at birth (p<0.04), as well as increased calf loss before weaning in both cows and heifers (p<0.02). There was also an increase in the risk of non-pregnancy for cows and heifers (p<0.001) where first exposure to breeding was not until July or August. In contrast, the risks of calf loss within 24 hrs of birth (p<0.001) and from 24 hrs to weaning in cows (p<0.02) first exposed to breeding in July and August were significantly lower than for herds that had earlier breeding seasons.