Department of Speech and Hearing Sciences, Lamar University, Beaumont, Texas.
Department of Speech and Hearing Sciences, Lamar University, Beaumont, Texas.
J Voice. 2020 Nov;34(6):962.e1-962.e7. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2019.06.011. Epub 2019 Jul 23.
The study was aimed at assessing the suitability of English-language Internet health information related to vocal hygiene, vocal health, and prevention of voice disorders. We also examined the relation between suitability, readability, and quality of Internet health information.
Suitability of 77 websites from Dueppen et al was assessed using the Suitability Assessment of Materials tool. Information about readability and quality of the websites were extracted from Dueppen et al. RESULTS: The overall converted suitability percent score of all 77 websites was 66.4%, which represents "adequate" suitability. Individual websites were rated as superior (ie, 44.2%) adequate (ie, 51.9%), and not suitable (ie, 3.9%). No relation was found between website origin and the suitability ratings. The inter-rater reliability of the Suitability Assessment of Materials ratings for overall scale was found to be good. The suitability of websites had a moderate correlation with readability measures, but no significant correlation was observed between the suitability and quality of websites.
The study results suggest that overall suitability of websites on vocal hygiene are adequate. However, many websites may require improvements in some elements (eg, literacy demand, graphics, and learning stimulation). Readability, quality, and suitability are important components in the accessibility of health information for people with different health conditions. Hence, improvements in these elements are expected to improve the understanding and actionability of people with voice issues.
本研究旨在评估与嗓音卫生、嗓音健康和预防嗓音障碍相关的英文互联网健康信息的适宜性。我们还研究了适宜性、可理解性和互联网健康信息质量之间的关系。
使用材料适宜性评估工具评估 Dueppen 等人的 77 个网站的适宜性。从 Dueppen 等人的研究中提取有关网站可读性和质量的信息。
所有 77 个网站的总体适宜性转换百分比分得 66.4%,表示“适宜”。个别网站被评为优秀(即 44.2%)、适宜(即 51.9%)和不适宜(即 3.9%)。网站来源与适宜性评分之间没有关系。材料适宜性评估的整体尺度的评分者间信度被认为是良好的。网站的适宜性与可读性测量值之间存在中度相关性,但在网站的适宜性与质量之间未观察到显著相关性。
研究结果表明,关于嗓音卫生的网站的总体适宜性是足够的。然而,许多网站可能需要在某些方面进行改进(例如,读写能力需求、图形和学习激励)。可理解性、质量和适宜性是不同健康状况的人获取健康信息的重要组成部分。因此,预计这些元素的改进将提高有嗓音问题的人的理解和可操作性。