Nayeri Fatemeh, Asghari Fariba, Baser Ali, Janani Leila, Shariat Mamak, Tanha Kiarash, Eabrhim Bita
Professor, Family Health Institute, Maternal, Fetal and Neonatal Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Associate Professor, Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
J Med Ethics Hist Med. 2019 Jun 11;12:6. eCollection 2019.
Attitudes of physicians toward neonates with poor prognosis greatly influence their decisions regarding the course of treatment and care. The present study aimed to investigate factors contributing to attitudes of medical practitioners toward poor prognosis neonates. This was a cross-sectional, descriptive-analytic study. Questionnaires for assessing subjects' attitudes toward care of very poor prognosis neonates were administered to all neonatologists, pediatricians, neonatology assistants, and pediatric residents (a total of 88 individuals) working in the NICUs of Imam Khomeini Hospital. Participants' attitudes were determined through analysis of responses to seven questions on a 5-point Likert scale ranging from "strongly agree" to "strongly disagree". Presence of anomalies incompatible with an acceptable quality of life, birth weight, gestational age, responses to neonatal diagnostic tests, certain types of diseases, parental marital status and practitioner predictions about patient prognosis were the factors contributing to practitioners' attitude (-value < 0.005). However, no significant relationship was found in connection with religious beliefs, socioeconomic status, opinions of consulting physicians, hospital treatment protocols, standards of the Association of Neonatal Physicians, and ethics committee expectations (-value > 0.005). It can be concluded that the attitudes of practitioners toward intensive care of poor prognosis neonates is determined by the medical condition of the neonate rather than socio-demographic characteristics.
医生对预后不良新生儿的态度极大地影响他们在治疗和护理过程中的决策。本研究旨在调查影响医务人员对预后不良新生儿态度的因素。这是一项横断面描述性分析研究。我们向在伊玛目·霍梅尼医院新生儿重症监护病房工作的所有新生儿科医生、儿科医生、新生儿科助理和儿科住院医师(共88人)发放了评估他们对预后极差新生儿护理态度的问卷。通过分析对七个问题的回答来确定参与者的态度,这些问题采用从“强烈同意”到“强烈不同意”的5点李克特量表。与可接受生活质量不相容的异常情况、出生体重、胎龄、新生儿诊断测试结果、某些类型的疾病、父母婚姻状况以及医生对患者预后的预测是影响医生态度的因素(P值<0.005)。然而,在宗教信仰、社会经济地位、会诊医生意见、医院治疗方案、新生儿医师协会标准以及伦理委员会期望方面未发现显著关系(P值>0.005)。可以得出结论,医务人员对预后不良新生儿重症监护的态度取决于新生儿的医疗状况而非社会人口学特征。