Department of Radiation Oncology, University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, USA.
Department of Radiation Oncology, Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India.
Br J Radiol. 2019 Nov;92(1103):20190174. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20190174. Epub 2019 Aug 12.
The effect of functional lung avoidance planning on radiation dose-dependent changes in regional lung perfusion is unknown. We characterized dose-perfusion response on longitudinal perfusion single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT)/CT in two cohorts of lung cancer patients treated with and without functional lung avoidance techniques.
The study included 28 primary lung cancer patients: 20 from interventional (NCT02773238) (FLARE-RT) and eight from observational (NCT01982123) (LUNG-RT) clinical trials. FLARE-RT treatment plans included perfused lung dose constraints while LUNG-RT plans adhered to clinical standards. Pre- and 3 month post-treatment macro-aggregated albumin (MAA) SPECT/CT scans were rigidly co-registered to planning four-dimensional CT scans. Tumour-subtracted lung dose was converted to EQD2 and sorted into 5 Gy bins. Mean dose and percent change between pre/post-RT MAA-SPECT uptake (%ΔPERF), normalized to total tumour-subtracted lung uptake, were calculated in each binned dose region. Perfusion frequency histograms of pre/post-RT MAA-SPECT were analyzed. Dose-response data were parameterized by sigmoid logistic functions to estimate maximum perfusion increase (maxincrease), maximum perfusion decrease (maxdecrease), dose midpoint (mid), and dose-response slope ().
Differences in MAA perfusion frequency distribution shape between time points were observed in 11/20 (55%) FLARE-RT and 2/8 (25%) LUNG-RT patients ( < 0.05). FLARE-RT dose response was characterized by >10% perfusion increase in the 0-5 Gy dose bin for 8/20 patients (maxincrease = 10-40%), which was not observed in any LUNG-RT patients ( = 0.03). The dose midpoint mid at which relative perfusion declined by 50% trended higher in FLARE-RT compared to LUNG-RT cohorts (35 GyEQD2 21 GyEQD2, = 0.09), while the dose-response slope was similar between FLARE-RT and LUNG-RT cohorts (3.1-3.2, = 0.86).
Functional lung avoidance planning may promote increased post-treatment perfusion in low dose regions for select patients, though inter-patient variability remains high in unbalanced cohorts. These preliminary findings form testable hypotheses that warrant subsequent validation in larger cohorts within randomized or case-matched control investigations.
This novel preliminary study reports differences in dose-response relationships between patients receiving functional lung avoidance radiation therapy (FLARE-RT) and those receiving conventionally planned radiation therapy (LUNG-RT). Following further validation and testing of these effects in larger patient populations, individualized estimation of regional lung perfusion dose-response may help refine future risk-adaptive strategies to minimize lung function deficits and toxicity incidence.
功能肺回避计划对与辐射剂量相关的区域性肺灌注变化的影响尚不清楚。我们描述了在接受和未接受功能肺回避技术治疗的肺癌患者的两个队列的纵向灌注单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)/CT 上的剂量-灌注反应。
这项研究纳入了 28 例原发性肺癌患者:20 例来自介入性(NCT02773238)(FLARE-RT)队列,8 例来自观察性(NCT01982123)(LUNG-RT)队列。FLARE-RT 治疗计划包括有灌注肺剂量限制,而 LUNG-RT 计划则遵守临床标准。在治疗前和治疗后 3 个月进行大颗粒白蛋白(MAA)SPECT/CT 扫描,并与计划的四维 CT 扫描进行刚性配准。将肿瘤减去的肺剂量转换为 EQD2,并按 5 Gy -bin 进行排序。在每个分组剂量区域中,计算了肿瘤减去的肺剂量与总肿瘤减去的肺摄取量的比值(%ΔPERF)的治疗前后 MAA-SPECT 摄取的平均剂量和变化百分比。分析了治疗前后 MAA-SPECT 的灌注频率直方图。通过 sigmoid 逻辑函数对剂量反应数据进行参数化,以估计最大灌注增加量(maxincrease)、最大灌注减少量(maxdecrease)、剂量中点(mid)和剂量反应斜率()。
在 20 例 FLARE-RT 患者中有 11 例(55%)和 8 例 LUNG-RT 患者中有 2 例(25%)观察到治疗前后 MAA 灌注频率分布形状存在差异(<0.05)。FLARE-RT 的剂量反应特征是在 0-5 Gy 剂量 bin 中灌注增加>10%,20 例患者中有 8 例(maxincrease=10-40%),而在任何 LUNG-RT 患者中均未观察到(=0.03)。与 LUNG-RT 队列相比,FLARE-RT 队列中相对灌注下降 50%的剂量中点 mid 趋势较高(35 GyEQD2 >21 GyEQD2,=0.09),而 FLARE-RT 和 LUNG-RT 队列之间的剂量反应斜率相似(3.1-3.2,=0.86)。
功能肺回避计划可能会促进某些患者在低剂量区域治疗后的灌注增加,尽管在不平衡的队列中,患者间的变异性仍然很高。这些初步发现形成了可测试的假设,需要在更大的随机或病例匹配对照研究中进一步验证。
本初步研究报告了接受功能肺回避放射治疗(FLARE-RT)的患者与接受常规计划放射治疗(LUNG-RT)的患者之间剂量反应关系的差异。在更大的患者人群中进一步验证和测试这些影响后,对区域性肺灌注剂量反应的个体化估计可能有助于完善未来的风险适应策略,以最大限度地减少肺功能缺陷和毒性发生率。