Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Virginia, Christiansburg, VA, United States.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2019 Jul 30;7(7):e14785. doi: 10.2196/14785.
A high consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) poses significant health concerns, particularly for rural adults and adolescents. A manner in which the health of both caregivers and adolescents can be improved is by developing innovative strategies that target caregivers as the agents of change. Sending text messages through mobile phones has been cited as an effective way to improve behavioral outcomes, although little research has been conducted in rural areas, particularly focusing on SSB intake.
By targeting rural caregivers, this 2-phase study aimed to (1) understand caregivers' perceptions and language preferences for SSB-related text messages to inform and refine message development and delivery and (2) evaluate the acceptability of text messages for SSB intake behavior change and examine short-term effects on SSB intake behavior.
A convergent mixed methods design was used to systematically develop and pilot-test text messages with caregivers in Southwest Virginia. In phase 1, 5 focus groups that included a card-sorting activity were conducted to explore advantages/disadvantages, language preferences (ie, tone of voice, audience, and phrase preferences), and perceived use of text messages. In phase 2, caregivers participated in a 5-week text message pilot trial that included weekly educational and personalized strategy messages and SSB intake assessments at baseline and follow-up. Before the focus groups and after completing the pilot trial, caregivers also completed a pre-post survey that assessed SSB intake, SSB home availability, and caregivers' SSB-related practices. Caregivers also completed individual follow-up telephone interviews following the pilot trial.
In phase 1, caregivers (N=33) reported that text messages were convenient, accessible, and easy to read. In addition, they preferred messages with empathetic and authoritative tones that provided useful strategies and stayed away from using absolute words (eg, always and never). In the phase 2 pilot trial (N=30), 87% of caregivers completed baseline and 77% completed follow-up assessment, suggesting a high utilization rate. Other ways in which caregivers reported benefiting from the text messages included sharing messages with family members and friends (80%), making mental notes (57%), and looking back at messages as reminders (50%). Caregivers reported significant improvements in home environment, parenting practices, and rulemaking around SSB (P=.003, P=.02, and P=.04, respectively). In addition, the frequency of SSB intake among caregivers and adolescents significantly decreased (P=.003 and P=.005, respectively).
Spending time in the formative phases of text message development helped understand the unique perspectives and language preferences of the target population. Furthermore, delivering an intervention through text messages has the potential to improve caregiver behaviors and reduce SSB intake among rural caregivers and adolescents. Findings from this study were used to develop a larger bank of text messages, which would be used in a future study, testing the effectiveness of a text message intervention targeting SSB intake-related caregiver behaviors.
大量饮用含糖饮料(SSBs)对健康有重大影响,尤其是对农村成年人和青少年。改善照顾者和青少年健康的一种方法是制定创新策略,以照顾者为变革的推动者。通过手机发送短信已被证明是一种改善行为结果的有效方法,尽管很少有研究在农村地区进行,特别是针对 SSB 摄入量。
本两阶段研究针对农村照顾者,旨在(1)了解照顾者对 SSB 相关短信的看法和语言偏好,以提供信息并完善信息的开发和传递;(2)评估短信对 SSB 摄入行为改变的可接受性,并检验其对 SSB 摄入行为的短期影响。
采用收敛混合方法设计,在弗吉尼亚州西南部与照顾者一起系统地开发和试点测试短信。在第 1 阶段,进行了 5 次焦点小组讨论,其中包括卡片分类活动,以探讨优点/缺点、语言偏好(即语气、受众和短语偏好)以及对短信的感知使用。在第 2 阶段,照顾者参加了为期 5 周的短信试点试验,其中包括每周的教育和个性化策略信息以及基线和随访时的 SSB 摄入量评估。在参加焦点小组之前和完成试点试验之后,照顾者还完成了一项关于 SSB 摄入量、SSB 家庭供应情况以及照顾者 SSB 相关做法的预-后调查。照顾者还在试点试验后进行了单独的后续电话访谈。
在第 1 阶段,照顾者(N=33)报告说短信方便、可及且易于阅读。此外,他们更喜欢使用富有同情心和权威性语气的短信,这些短信提供有用的策略,避免使用绝对的词语(例如,总是和从不)。在第 2 阶段的试点试验(N=30)中,87%的照顾者完成了基线评估,77%的照顾者完成了随访评估,表明利用率较高。照顾者报告说,他们从短信中受益的其他方式包括与家人和朋友分享短信(80%)、记笔记(57%)和将短信作为提醒(50%)。照顾者报告说,家庭环境、育儿做法和 SSB 规则制定方面有显著改善(P=.003、P=.02 和 P=.04,分别)。此外,照顾者和青少年的 SSB 摄入量显著减少(P=.003 和 P=.005,分别)。
在短信开发的形成阶段投入时间有助于了解目标人群的独特观点和语言偏好。此外,通过短信发送干预信息有可能改善农村照顾者的行为,减少 SSB 摄入量。本研究的结果用于开发更大的短信库,这将在未来的研究中使用,测试针对 SSB 摄入相关照顾者行为的短信干预措施的有效性。