Shayman Corey S, Ha Yi-Min, Raz Yael, Hullar Timothy E
Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Oregon Health & Science University, Portland.
Operative Care Division, Veterans Health Administration Portland Health Care System, Portland, Oregon.
JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2019 Oct 1;145(10):889-896. doi: 10.1001/jamaoto.2019.1918.
Veterans are at high risk for developing sensorineural hearing loss leading to cochlear implant (CI) candidacy; however, the ability to care for these patients is limited by the number and location of Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities that provide specialized CI services.
To investigate geographic disparities in access to CI care within the VHA system for US veterans.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: An analysis of census tract-level data including US veterans was conducted using the nationwide American Community Survey data collected by the US Census Bureau from January to December 2016, which were accessed in 2017.
Maps showing the geographic variability in need for specialized CI services, estimated as a function of the number of veterans and the distance to the nearest established VHA-based CI surgical or audiologic facilities.
A total of 19.9 million veterans within the continental United States resided at a median distance of 80 miles (interquartile range [IQR], 30.1-140.9 miles; mean [SD], 1002 [465.8] miles) from the nearest VHA facility offering CI care; of these, 3.98 million (20.0%) resided more than 160.7 miles from the nearest VHA facility. When considering only comprehensive facilities offering both surgical and audiologic care, the median distance was 101.3 miles (IQR, 39.4-178.7 miles; mean [SD], 126.0 [448.4] miles), but 20.0% of veterans had to travel more than 201.0 miles to a VHA facility. Veterans residing in urban areas (74.0%) lived a median distance of 61.2 miles (IQR, 23.7-121.3 miles; mean [SD], 83.8 [477.1] miles) from the nearest VHA facility, with 2.9 million (20.0%) living the farthest at 140.7 miles. Veterans residing in rural areas (26.0%) lived a median distance of 119.8 miles (IQR, 79.0-182.4 miles; mean [SD], 146.9 [431.0] miles) from their nearest VHA facility, with 1.04 million (20.0%) living more than 206.2 miles from the nearest VHA facility.
This study's findings suggest that large disparities exist in the distance to the nearest VHA-based CI facilities. Veterans face considerable geographic barriers to obtaining VHA-based CI care in many parts of the country, including some large metropolitan areas. Those requiring only audiologic services face similar geographic barriers as those requiring surgery. Thoughtful placement of new facilities, along with upcoming advances in remote programming of implants, may help ensure appropriate care for this high-risk population.
退伍军人患感音神经性听力损失并因此符合人工耳蜗植入(CI)条件的风险很高;然而,为这些患者提供护理的能力受到提供专门CI服务的退伍军人健康管理局(VHA)设施数量和地点的限制。
调查美国退伍军人在VHA系统内获得CI护理方面的地理差异。
设计、设置和参与者:使用美国人口普查局于2016年1月至12月收集并于2017年获取的全国性美国社区调查数据,对包括美国退伍军人在内的普查区层面数据进行分析。
显示对专门CI服务需求的地理变异性的地图,该需求根据退伍军人数量以及到最近的基于VHA的CI手术或听力设施的距离来估算。
美国大陆共有1990万退伍军人,他们距离提供CI护理的最近VHA设施的中位距离为80英里(四分位间距[IQR],30.1 - 140.9英里;均值[标准差],1002[465.8]英里);其中,398万(20.0%)居住在距离最近VHA设施超过160.7英里的地方。仅考虑提供手术和听力护理的综合设施时,中位距离为101.3英里(IQR,39.4 - 178.7英里;均值[标准差],126.0[448.4]英里),但20.0%的退伍军人必须前往距离超过201.0英里的VHA设施。居住在城市地区的退伍军人(74.0%)距离最近VHA设施的中位距离为61.2英里(IQR,23.7 - 121.3英里;均值[标准差],83.8[477.1]英里),其中290万(20.0%)居住在最远达140.7英里的地方。居住在农村地区的退伍军人(26.0%)距离最近VHA设施的中位距离为119.8英里(IQR,79.0 - 182.4英里;均值[标准差],146.9[431.0]英里),其中104万(20.0%)居住在距离最近VHA设施超过206.2英里的地方。
本研究结果表明,到最近的基于VHA的CI设施的距离存在很大差异。在该国许多地区,包括一些大城市地区,退伍军人在获得基于VHA的CI护理方面面临相当大的地理障碍。仅需要听力服务的退伍军人面临与需要手术的退伍军人类似的地理障碍。合理布局新设施,以及即将在植入物远程编程方面取得的进展,可能有助于确保为这一高风险人群提供适当护理。