Department of Periodontology, National Engineering Laboratory for Digital and Material Technology of Stomatology, Beijing Key Laboratory of Digital Stomatology, Peking University School and Hospital of Stomatology, Beijing, China.
J Clin Periodontol. 2019 Nov;46(11):1094-1104. doi: 10.1111/jcpe.13177. Epub 2019 Aug 28.
To assess the subgingival microbial shift of maintained periodontitis treated by ultrasonic scaling (US) or air polishing (AP) during a 3-month maintenance interval.
We conducted a 12-week randomized split-mouth controlled trial with US and AP in 17 maintained subjects (bleeding on probing [BOP%] ≤25%, probing depth [PD] ≤5 mm). They were monitored at baseline, week 2, week 8 and week 12. The V3-V4 region of the 16S rDNA from 136 subgingival plaque samples was sequenced and analysed.
Treatment by US or AP could effectively reduce the PD, microbial richness, diversity, periodontitis-associated microbiota and pathogenic metabolism in maintained periodontitis. Bacteria recolonized after treatment and returned to the pre-treatment level 12 weeks after treatment. Ultrasonic scaling group demonstrated slight advantage in reducing BOP (%), pathogenic bacteria and metabolism than AP group. Pathogenic microbiota and commensal microbiota kept a balance in subgingival community of maintained patients during the 3-month interval.
Treatment by US or AP effectively reduced the pathogenicity of subgingival microbiome by reducing microbial diversity, proportion of periodontitis-associated microbiota and pathogenic metabolism. It helped to keep a balanced subgingival community and stable periodontal condition over a single maintenance interval of 3 months.
评估超声洁治(US)或空气抛光(AP)治疗维持期牙周炎在 3 个月的维持间隔期间龈下微生物的变化。
我们进行了一项为期 12 周的随机分口对照试验,纳入了 17 名接受 US 和 AP 治疗的维持期牙周炎患者(探诊出血百分比 [BOP%]≤25%,探诊深度 [PD]≤5mm)。他们在基线、第 2 周、第 8 周和第 12 周进行监测。对 136 个龈下菌斑样本的 16S rDNA 的 V3-V4 区进行测序和分析。
US 或 AP 治疗可有效降低 PD、微生物丰富度、多样性、牙周病相关微生物群和致病代谢物在维持性牙周炎中的水平。治疗后细菌重新定植,并在治疗后 12 周恢复到治疗前水平。与 AP 组相比,超声洁治组在降低 BOP(%)、致病菌和代谢物方面略有优势。在 3 个月的间隔期内,维持患者的龈下菌群中,致病菌群和共生菌群保持平衡。
US 或 AP 治疗通过降低微生物多样性、牙周病相关微生物群的比例和致病代谢物的水平,有效降低龈下微生物组的致病性。它有助于在单个 3 个月的维持间隔内保持平衡的龈下菌群和稳定的牙周状况。