Department of Psychology (Zottola, Desmarais, Neupert) and Department of Statistics (Dong, Laber), North Carolina State University, Raleigh; Department of Criminology, Law and Society, George Mason University, Fairfax, Virginia; (Lowder); RTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina (Van Dorn).
Psychiatr Serv. 2019 Nov 1;70(11):1006-1012. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201800377. Epub 2019 Aug 5.
The Brief Jail Mental Health Screen (BJMHS) is widely used at intake in county jails to identify detainees who may have serious mental illness and who should be referred for further mental health evaluation. The BJMHS may be administered multiple times across repeated jail bookings; however, the extent to which results may change over time is unclear. To that end, the authors examined the odds of screening positive on the BJMHS across repeated jail bookings.
Data were drawn from the administrative and medical records of a large, urban county jail that used the BJMHS at jail booking. The study sample comprised BJMHS results for the 12,531 jail detainees who were booked at least twice during the 3.5-year period (N=41,965 bookings). Multilevel logistic modeling was used to examine changes over time overall and within the four decision rules (current psychiatric medication, prior hospitalization, two or more current symptoms, and referral for any other reason).
Results show that the odds of a positive screen overall increased with each jail booking, as did the odds of referral for any other reason. In contrast, the odds of screening positive for two or more current symptoms and prior hospitalization decreased. There was no change in the odds of screening positive for current psychiatric medication across bookings.
Findings show that BJMHS results changed across bookings. Further research is needed to determine whether changes reflect true changes in mental health status, issues with fidelity, the repeated nature of the screening process, or other factors.
Brief Jail Mental Health Screen(BJMHS)在县级监狱的入监时被广泛用于识别可能患有严重精神疾病的被拘留者,并应将其转介进行进一步的心理健康评估。BJMHS 可能会在多次重复的监狱预订中多次进行;然而,结果随时间变化的程度尚不清楚。为此,作者研究了在重复的监狱预订中 BJMHS 筛查阳性的几率。
数据来自使用 BJMHS 在监狱预订时进行的大型城市县级监狱的行政和医疗记录。研究样本包括在 3.5 年期间至少预订两次的 12531 名监狱被拘留者的 BJMHS 结果(N=41965 次预订)。多级逻辑模型用于检查总体和四个决策规则(当前精神科药物、先前住院治疗、两个或更多当前症状以及因任何其他原因转介)内的随时间变化。
结果表明,整体而言,阳性筛查的几率随着每次监狱预订而增加,因任何其他原因转介的几率也是如此。相比之下,筛查出两个或更多当前症状和先前住院治疗的几率下降。在预订过程中,筛查出当前精神科药物呈阳性的几率没有变化。
研究结果表明 BJMHS 结果在预订过程中发生了变化。需要进一步研究以确定这些变化是否反映了心理健康状况的真实变化、保真度问题、筛查过程的重复性或其他因素。