Alsuwaiyan Nahlah A, Mohring Margaret B, Cambridge Marion, Coleman Melinda A, Kendrick Gary A, Wernberg Thomas
School of Biological Sciences and UWA Oceans Institute University of Western Australia Crawley Western Australia Australia.
Department of Biology Unaizah College of Sciences and Arts, Qassim University Unaizah Saudi Arabia.
Ecol Evol. 2019 Jun 20;9(14):8387-8398. doi: 10.1002/ece3.5389. eCollection 2019 Jul.
Kelps (order Laminariales) are foundation species in temperate and arctic seas globally, but they are in decline in many places. Laminarian kelp have an alternation of generations and this poses challenges for experimental studies due to the difficulties in achieving zoospore release and gametophyte growth. Here, we review and synthesize the protocols that have been used to induce zoospore release in kelps to identify commonalities and provide guidance on best practices. We found 171 papers, where zoospore release was induced in four kelp families from 35 different ecoregions. The most commonly treated family was Laminariaceae, followed by Lessoniaceae and the most studied ecoregion was Central Chile, followed by the Southern California Bight. Zoospore release generally involved three steps: a pretreatment which included cleaning of the reproductive tissue to eliminate epiphytic organisms, followed by desiccation of the tissue, and finally a postdesiccation immersion of the reproductive material in a seawater medium for zoospore release. Despite these commonalities, there was a high degree of variation in the detail within each of these steps, even among studies within genera and from the same ecoregions. This suggests either that zoospore release may be relatively insensitive across the Laminariales or that little methods optimization has been undertaken. We suggest that greater attention to standardization of protocols and reporting of methodology and optimization would improve comparisons of kelp zoospore release across species and locations and facilitate a broader understanding of this key, but understudied life history stage.
This article has earned an Open Data Badge for making publicly available the digitally-shareable data necessary to reproduce the reported results. The data is available at https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.0kh1f8j.
海带(海带目)是全球温带和北极海域的基础物种,但在许多地方它们的数量正在减少。海带具有世代交替现象,由于难以实现游动孢子的释放和配子体的生长,这给实验研究带来了挑战。在这里,我们回顾并综合了用于诱导海带游动孢子释放的实验方案,以找出共同点并提供最佳实践指导。我们发现了171篇论文,其中在来自35个不同生态区域的四个海带科中诱导了游动孢子的释放。最常处理的科是海带科,其次是巨藻科,研究最多的生态区域是智利中部,其次是南加州湾。游动孢子的释放一般包括三个步骤:预处理,包括清洁生殖组织以消除附生生物,然后使组织干燥,最后将干燥后的生殖材料浸入海水介质中以释放游动孢子。尽管存在这些共同点,但这些步骤中的每一个步骤在细节上都存在很大差异,即使是同一属内以及来自相同生态区域的研究之间也是如此。这表明要么游动孢子的释放在海带目中可能相对不敏感,要么很少有人进行方法优化。我们建议更多地关注实验方案的标准化、方法学的报告和优化,这将改善不同物种和地点海带游动孢子释放的比较,并有助于更广泛地了解这个关键但研究不足的生活史阶段。
本文因公开提供重现报告结果所需的数字可共享数据而获得开放数据徽章。数据可在https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.0kh1f8j获取。