Hunter Kimberly, Thomson Ben
Department of Family Medicine, Global Health and Vulnerable Populations, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Medicine, International Health Professional Education Working Group, Queen's University, Ontario, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2019 Jul 24;10(3):e61-e71. eCollection 2019 Jul.
Social determinants of health are responsible for 50% of ill health. The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada CanMEDS role of "physician advocate" requires physicians to attain competency in this particular domain, but physician trainees feel this is not well covered in their training programs. This study performed a scoping review of social determinants of health curricula that had been described, implemented and evaluated in post-graduate medical education. A search using MEDLINE(OvidSP) database, with search terms "residency," "curriculum," and "social determinants" with no age, language, and publication date restrictions was done. Researchers identified a total of 12 studies, all from the United States, in internal medicine (n=4), pediatrics (n=4), family medicine (n=2), or multiple (n=2) residency programs. Most curricula (n=8, 67%), were longitudinal, and most contained both patient or community exposure (n=11, 92%) and/or classroom-based components (n=10, 83%). Most (78%) curricula improved participant related outcomes, including exam performance, awareness regarding personal practice, confidence, improved screening for social determinants of health and referral to support services. Program specific outcomes were frequently positive (50%) and included resident satisfaction and high course evaluation scores, high representation of resident and faculty from minority groups, applicability of training to underserviced populations, and improved engagement of marginalized community members. When evaluated, academic outcomes were always positive, and included acceptance of scholarly projects to national conferences, publication of research work, grants earned to support health projects, local or national awards for leadership and community engagement, and curriculum graduates later pursuing related Masters degrees and/or establishing medical practices in underserved areas. Only one study reported a patient-related outcome, with advice provided by health care providers considered by patients to be helpful. Researchers used these results to design recommendations for creation of a post-graduate curriculum to address social determinants of health were provided.
健康的社会决定因素导致了50%的健康问题。加拿大皇家内科医师与外科医师学院的“医师倡导者”这一CanMEDS角色要求医师在这一特定领域具备能力,但医师培训学员认为他们的培训项目对此覆盖不足。本研究对研究生医学教育中已被描述、实施和评估的健康社会决定因素课程进行了范围综述。使用MEDLINE(OvidSP)数据库进行了检索,检索词为“住院医师培训”“课程”和“社会决定因素”,无年龄、语言和出版日期限制。研究人员共确定了12项研究,均来自美国,涉及内科(n = 4)、儿科(n = 4)、家庭医学(n = 2)或多个(n = 2)住院医师培训项目。大多数课程(n = 8,67%)是纵向的,且大多数包含患者或社区接触(n = 11,92%)和/或课堂教学部分(n = 10,83%)。大多数(78%)课程改善了参与者的相关结果,包括考试成绩、对个人实践的认识、信心、改善对健康社会决定因素的筛查以及转介至支持服务。项目特定结果通常是积极的(50%),包括住院医师满意度和高课程评价分数、少数群体住院医师和教员的高比例代表、培训对服务不足人群的适用性以及边缘化社区成员参与度的提高。在评估时,学术成果总是积极的,包括学术项目被全国性会议接受、研究工作发表、获得资助以支持健康项目、获得地方或国家的领导力和社区参与奖项,以及课程毕业生后来攻读相关硕士学位和/或在服务不足地区建立医疗实践。只有一项研究报告了与患者相关的结果,患者认为医疗保健提供者提供的建议很有帮助。研究人员利用这些结果为创建研究生课程以解决健康的社会决定因素提供了设计建议。