IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2019 Sep;27(9):1714-1723. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2019.2934496. Epub 2019 Aug 12.
A brain-computer interface (BCI) provides a novel non-muscular communication pathway for individuals with severe neuromuscular diseases. BCI systems based on steady-state visual evoked potentials (SSVEPs) have high classification accuracy, information transfer rate, and signal-to-noise ratio, giving them high research and application value. However, SSVEP-based BCI has several limitations in real-world applications. The main challenge is how to reduce or eliminate the need for a dedicated training process while maintaining high classification accuracy. Filter bank canonical correlation analysis (FBCCA) is a powerful and widely used feature extraction method for SSVEP-based BCI systems. However, the reference signals of FBCCA are fixed-frequency sine-cosine waves, which makes it difficult to accurately describe the complex, mutative, and individually different physiological SSVEPs. Therefore, there is huge room for improvement in classification performance based on the FBCCA method. In contrast, although spatiotemporal beamforming (BF) detects SSVEPs with high accuracy, it needs an additional training process, which limits its application. In this study, we propose a bimodal decoding algorithm (FBCCA+BF), which combines the advantages of the training-free classification of FBCCA and the data-driven and adaptive features of BF. Six-channel SSVEP data corresponding to eight targets measured from 15 subjects were used to test the effectiveness of three different CCA-based methods, BF, and our proposed FBCCA+BF methods. It was found that the classification accuracies for BF and FBCCA+BF are 95.6% and 92.2%, respectively, which are significantly higher than the other CCA-based methods. Notably, both BF and FBCCA+BF obtain state-of-the-art performance, but FBCCA+BF does this without the need for a dedicated training process. Therefore, we conclude that our proposed FBCCA+BF method provides a training-free and high-accuracy approach for SSVEP-based BCIs.
脑机接口(BCI)为严重神经肌肉疾病患者提供了一种新颖的非肌肉通讯途径。基于稳态视觉诱发电位(SSVEP)的 BCI 系统具有较高的分类准确性、信息传输率和信噪比,具有较高的研究和应用价值。然而,基于 SSVEP 的 BCI 在实际应用中存在一些局限性。主要的挑战是如何在保持高分类准确性的同时,减少或消除对专用训练过程的需求。滤波器组典型相关分析(FBCCA)是一种强大且广泛应用于基于 SSVEP 的 BCI 系统的特征提取方法。然而,FBCCA 的参考信号是固定频率的正弦余弦波,这使得它难以准确描述复杂、多变和个体差异的生理 SSVEP。因此,基于 FBCCA 方法的分类性能有很大的改进空间。相比之下,尽管时空波束形成(BF)可以高精度地检测 SSVEP,但它需要额外的训练过程,这限制了它的应用。在这项研究中,我们提出了一种双模解码算法(FBCCA+BF),它结合了 FBCCA 无训练分类的优势和 BF 的数据驱动和自适应特征。使用来自 15 名受试者的 8 个目标的 6 通道 SSVEP 数据来测试三种不同基于 CCA 的方法、BF 和我们提出的 FBCCA+BF 方法的有效性。结果发现,BF 和 FBCCA+BF 的分类准确率分别为 95.6%和 92.2%,明显高于其他基于 CCA 的方法。值得注意的是,BF 和 FBCCA+BF 都获得了最先进的性能,但 FBCCA+BF 无需专用训练过程即可实现这一目标。因此,我们得出结论,我们提出的 FBCCA+BF 方法为基于 SSVEP 的 BCI 提供了一种无训练和高精度的方法。