Ciccozzi Massimo, Cella Eleonora, Lai Alessia, De Florio Lucia, Antonelli Francesca, Fogolari Marta, Di Matteo Francesco Maria, Pizzicannella Margherita, Colombo Benedetta, Dicuonzo Giordano, Angeletti Silvia
Unit of Medical Statistics and Molecular Epidemiology, University Campus Bio-Medico of Rome, Rome, Italy.
Department of Biomedical and Clinical Sciences "L. Sacco," University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
Front Public Health. 2019 Aug 6;7:219. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2019.00219. eCollection 2019.
Duodenoscopes have been described as potential vehicles of patient-to-patient transmission of multi-drug resistant organisms. Carbapenem-resistant duodenoscope related infections have been described by the Center for Disease Control and the US Food and Drug Administration consequently to outbreaks occurring in the United States. These evidences suggested that improved microbiological surveillance and endoscope design optimization could represent valid tools to improve infection control. At this aim, in this study an example of duodenoscope microbiological surveillance and reprocessing improvement analyzing strains component of bacterial biofilm by phylogenetic analysis has been proposed. From September 2016 to December 2017, duodenoscope instruments were subjected to microbial surveillance by post-reprocessing cultures of liquid collected by internal channels of instruments after injection and aspiration cycles and membrane filtration. During surveillance seventeen , of which 10/17 (58.8%) MDR and KPC strains were collected from duodenoscope instruments plus one MDR strain from the rectal swab performed before ERCP procedure in an inpatient. The surveillance allowed evidencing potential failure of reprocessing procedure and performing consequent reprocessing improvements including the contaminated instruments quarantine until their negativity. Phylogenetic analysis of whole genome sequence of duodenoscope strains plus inpatients MDR strains, showed intermixing between duodenoscopes and inpatients, as evidenced by minimum spanning tree and time-scale Maximum Clade Credibility tree. In minimum spanning tree, three groups have been evidenced. Group I including strains, isolated from inpatients before microbiological surveillance adoption; group II including intermixed strains isolated from inpatients and strains isolated from duedonoscopes and group III including strains exclusively from duedonoscope instruments. In the Maximum Credibility Tree, a statistically supported cluster including two strains from duedonoscope instruments and one strains isolated from an inpatient was showed. From the first microbiologic surveillance performed on September 2016 and after the reprocessing improvement adoption, none MDR or susceptible strain was isolated in the following surveillance periods. In conclusion, these results should encourage hospital board to perform microbiological surveillance of duodenoscopes as well as of patients, by rectal swabs culture, and rapid molecular testing for antimicrobial resistance before any endoscopic invasive procedure.
十二指肠镜已被描述为耐多药生物体在患者间传播的潜在载体。美国疾病控制中心和美国食品药品监督管理局描述了与碳青霉烯类耐药十二指肠镜相关的感染,这些感染是在美国发生的疫情之后出现的。这些证据表明,改进微生物监测和优化内镜设计可能是改善感染控制的有效手段。为此,在本研究中,我们提出了一个通过系统发育分析来分析细菌生物膜菌株组成,以改进十二指肠镜微生物监测和再处理的实例。2016年9月至2017年12月,通过对器械内部通道在注射和抽吸循环后收集的液体进行后处理培养及膜过滤,对十二指肠镜器械进行微生物监测。在监测期间,从十二指肠镜器械中收集到17株菌株,其中10/17(58.8%)为耐多药菌株和产KPC酶菌株,另外在一名住院患者进行内镜逆行胰胆管造影(ERCP)手术前采集的直肠拭子中分离出1株耐多药菌株。该监测揭示了再处理程序可能存在的失败情况,并随后进行了再处理改进,包括对受污染器械进行隔离,直至检测为阴性。对十二指肠镜菌株以及住院患者耐多药菌株的全基因组序列进行系统发育分析,最小生成树和时间尺度最大分支可信度树表明十二指肠镜菌株与住院患者菌株之间存在混合。在最小生成树中,可分为三组。第一组包括在采用微生物监测之前从住院患者中分离出的菌株;第二组包括从住院患者中分离出的混合菌株以及从十二指肠镜中分离出的菌株;第三组仅包括从十二指肠镜器械中分离出的菌株。在最大可信度树中,显示出一个具有统计学支持的聚类,包括来自十二指肠镜器械的2株菌株和从一名住院患者中分离出的1株菌株。自2016年9月首次进行微生物监测并采用再处理改进措施后,在随后的监测期间未分离出耐多药菌株或敏感菌株。总之,这些结果应促使医院管理部门通过直肠拭子培养对十二指肠镜以及患者进行微生物监测,并在任何内镜侵入性操作前进行抗菌药物耐药性的快速分子检测。