Ohio University, USA.
American University of Sharjah, United Arab Emirates.
Public Underst Sci. 2019 Nov;28(8):949-957. doi: 10.1177/0963662519869815. Epub 2019 Aug 28.
Research shows that people in predominantly Christian cultures tend to perceive a basic tension between science and religion, which is not reflected in predominantly Muslim cultures. In this cross-cultural study comparing Christian university students in the United States and Muslim university students in the United Arab Emirates, we examined time spent in Western countries (for UAE students) or overseas (for American students) as predictors of perceived religion-science compatibility. Drawing upon the notion that science is viewed as more secular in Christianity than in Islam, we hypothesized and found that among UAE students, number of weeks per year spent in the West correlated negatively with religion-science compatibility beliefs. This relationship held even when controlling for science knowledge, suggesting that it results not from epistemological opposition to science but from an increasing exposure to the idea that science should be seen as a secular institution. Among American students, number of weeks per year spent overseas and religion-science compatibility beliefs were not associated. Implications for perceptions of science among different religious groups and in different cultural contexts are discussed.
研究表明,在主要信奉基督教的文化中,人们往往会感觉到科学与宗教之间存在基本的紧张关系,而这种关系在主要信奉伊斯兰教的文化中并不存在。在这项跨文化研究中,我们比较了美国的基督教大学生和阿拉伯联合酋长国的穆斯林大学生,考察了在西方国家(对于阿联酋学生而言)或海外(对于美国学生而言)度过的时间是否可以预测对宗教与科学兼容性的看法。根据科学在基督教中比在伊斯兰教中被视为更世俗的观点,我们假设并发现,在阿联酋学生中,每年在西方度过的周数与宗教与科学兼容性的信念呈负相关。即使在控制了科学知识之后,这种关系仍然成立,这表明这并不是由于对科学的认识论反对,而是由于越来越多地接受了这样一种观点,即科学应该被视为一个世俗的机构。而对于美国学生而言,每年在海外度过的周数与宗教与科学兼容性的信念之间没有关联。讨论了不同宗教群体和不同文化背景下对科学的看法的影响。