MS3 Medical Student, University of Toledo, Toledo, OhioUSA.
Professor, School of Population Health, University of Toledo, Toledo, OhioUSA.
Prehosp Disaster Med. 2019 Oct;34(5):481-485. doi: 10.1017/S1049023X19004710. Epub 2019 Aug 28.
Herd immunity, a concept normally applied in vaccinated populations, is a preventative measure to determine if a significant portion of a population can protect vulnerable individuals against a certain disease. Like vaccines, tourniquet education can be a form of herd immunity to protect vulnerable individuals in a population and prevent the loss of life from a peripheral hemorrhage. The authors have identified a deficiency in simple, quick, and effective hemorrhage control education. Therefore, to maximize herd immunity, the novel educational platform evaluates the efficacy of "Just-in-Time" (JiT) tourniquet application training.
HYPOTHESIS/PROBLEM: The authors hypothesize that the utilization of JiT training will be effective in promoting both competence and confidence for individuals to utilize tourniquets in response to a disaster environment.
This Institutional Review Board-approved study recruited medical students who were trained in hemorrhage control measures at a Level 1 Trauma Center. Tourniquet training sessions were held, and naïve civilians received tourniquet education. The subjects received a five- to ten-minute lesson on indications, contraindications, and application techniques of commercial and improvisational tourniquets. Participants subsequently applied a tourniquet to an instructor's arm to demonstrate proper tourniquet application for a brachial artery hemorrhage. Pre- and post-educational surveys were completed to test participant competency and confidence.
Of the 104 subjects who completed the course, 97 had no prior training in hemorrhage control techniques, including commercial and improvisational tourniquet application. The mean pre-test score was 2.27/5.00 and the mean post-test score was 4.38/5.00, P <.001 (n = 97). When queried "How competent would you feel applying a tourniquet (commercial or improvisational) on an individual with a bleeding wound?" 92/97 felt confident (95%), one felt less confident, and four felt no difference in confidence levels (P <.001).
Just-in-Time training is an effective method in teaching naïve civilians proper tourniquet application. This platform could serve as an alternative to more extensive training programs and requires less time, costs, and resources. If a significant number of individuals in a local community can effectively apply a tourniquet in a disaster scenario, a "herd immunity" effect could be achieved to control peripheral hemorrhages.
群体免疫是一个通常应用于接种疫苗人群的概念,它是一种预防措施,用于确定人群中的很大一部分是否可以保护弱势群体免受某种疾病的侵害。就像疫苗一样,止血带教育也可以是一种群体免疫形式,以保护人群中的弱势群体,并防止因外周出血导致的生命损失。作者已经发现了一种简单、快速和有效的止血控制教育的不足。因此,为了最大限度地发挥群体免疫的作用,新的教育平台评估了“即时”(Just-in-Time,JiT)止血带应用培训的效果。
假设/问题:作者假设,利用 JiT 培训将有效地促进个人在灾难环境中使用止血带的能力和信心。
这项经过机构审查委员会批准的研究招募了在一级创伤中心接受过出血控制措施培训的医学生。进行了止血带培训课程,让天真的平民接受止血带教育。学员们接受了关于商业和即兴止血带的适应症、禁忌症和应用技术的五到十分钟的课程。随后,参与者将止血带应用于讲师的手臂,以演示肱动脉出血时正确的止血带应用。完成了教育前后的调查,以测试参与者的能力和信心。
在完成课程的 104 名受试者中,有 97 名受试者以前没有接受过出血控制技术的培训,包括商业和即兴止血带应用。平均前测得分为 2.27/5.00,平均后测得分为 4.38/5.00,P<.001(n=97)。当被问及“您对应用止血带(商业或即兴)治疗有出血伤口的个体的信心如何?”97 名受试者中有 92 名(95%)感到有信心,1 名感到信心较低,4 名感到信心水平没有差异(P<.001)。
即时培训是向天真的平民教授正确止血带应用的有效方法。这个平台可以作为更广泛的培训计划的替代方案,需要的时间、成本和资源更少。如果当地社区的大量人员能够在灾难场景中有效地应用止血带,就可以实现控制外周出血的“群体免疫”效应。