Khademi April, Reiche Brittany, DiGregorio Justin, Arezza Giordano, Moody Alan R
Image Analysis in Medicine Lab (IAMLAB), Department of Electrical, Computer and Biomedical Engineering, Ryerson University, Toronto, ON M5B 2K3, Canada.
University of Guelph, Guelph, ON N1G 2W1, Canada.
Magn Reson Imaging. 2020 Feb;66:116-130. doi: 10.1016/j.mri.2019.08.022. Epub 2019 Aug 28.
Automatic segmentation of the brain from magnetic resonance images (MRI) is a fundamental step in many neuroimaging processing frameworks. There are mature technologies for this task for T1- and T2-weighted MRI; however, a widely-accepted brain extraction method for Fluid-Attenuated Inversion Recovery (FLAIR) MRI has yet to be established. FLAIR MRI are becoming increasingly important for the analysis of neurodegenerative diseases and tools developed for this sequence would have clinical value. To maximize translation opportunities and for large scale research studies, algorithms for brain extraction in FLAIR MRI should generalize to multi-centre (MC) data. To this end, this work proposes a fully automated, whole volume brain extraction methodology for MC FLAIR MRI datasets. The framework is built using a novel standardization framework which reduces acquisition artifacts, standardizes the intensities of tissues and normalizes the spatial coordinates of brain tissue across MC datasets. Using the standardized datasets, an intuitive set of features based on intensity, spatial location and gradients are extracted and classified using a random forest (RF) classifier to segment the brain tissue class. A series of experiments were conducted to optimize classifier parameters, and to determine segmentation accuracy for standardized and unstandardized (original) data, as a function of scanner vendor, feature type and disease type. The models are trained, tested and validated on 156 image volumes (∼8000 image slices) from two multi-centre, multi-disease datasets, acquired with varying imaging parameters from 30 centres and three scanner vendors. The image datasets, denoted as CAIN and ADNI for vascular and dementia disease, respectively, represent a diverse collection of MC data to test the generalization capabilities of the proposed design. Results demonstrate the importance of standardization for segmentation of MC data, as models trained on standardized data yielded a drastic improvement in brain extraction accuracy compared to the original, unstandardized data (CAIN: DSC = 91% and ADNI: DSC = 86% vs. CAIN: 78% and ADNI: 65%). It was also found that models created from one scanner vendor based on unstandardized data yielded poor segmentation results in data acquired from other scanner vendors, which was improved through standardization. These results demonstrate that to create consistency in segmentations from multi-institutional datasets it is paramount that MC variability be mitigated to improve stability and to ensure generalization of machine learning algorithms for MRI.
从磁共振成像(MRI)中自动分割大脑是许多神经影像处理框架中的基本步骤。对于T1加权和T2加权MRI,已有成熟的技术用于此任务;然而,一种被广泛接受的用于液体衰减反转恢复(FLAIR)MRI的脑提取方法尚未建立。FLAIR MRI在神经退行性疾病分析中变得越来越重要,为该序列开发的工具将具有临床价值。为了最大化转化机会并用于大规模研究,FLAIR MRI中的脑提取算法应能推广到多中心(MC)数据。为此,这项工作提出了一种用于MC FLAIR MRI数据集的全自动全脑提取方法。该框架是使用一种新颖的标准化框架构建的,该框架减少了采集伪影,标准化了组织强度,并使跨MC数据集的脑组织空间坐标归一化。使用标准化数据集,基于强度、空间位置和梯度提取一组直观的特征,并使用随机森林(RF)分类器进行分类,以分割脑组织类别。进行了一系列实验以优化分类器参数,并确定标准化和未标准化(原始)数据的分割准确性,作为扫描仪供应商、特征类型和疾病类型的函数。这些模型在来自两个多中心、多疾病数据集的156个图像体积(约8000个图像切片)上进行训练、测试和验证,这些数据是从30个中心和三个扫描仪供应商处获取的,具有不同的成像参数。这些图像数据集分别表示为用于血管疾病和痴呆疾病的CAIN和ADNI,代表了多种MC数据集合,用于测试所提出设计的泛化能力。结果表明标准化对于MC数据分割的重要性,因为与原始的未标准化数据相比,在标准化数据上训练的模型在脑提取准确性方面有显著提高(CAIN:DSC = 91%,ADNI:DSC = 86%,而CAIN:78%,ADNI:65%)。还发现,基于未标准化数据从一个扫描仪供应商创建的模型在从其他扫描仪供应商获取的数据中产生的分割结果很差,而通过标准化得到了改善。这些结果表明,为了在多机构数据集中的分割中创建一致性,减轻MC变异性以提高稳定性并确保MRI机器学习算法的泛化至关重要。