Wu John Z, Pan Christopher S, Wimer Bryan M
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA.
Eng Fail Anal. 2019 Feb;96:330-339. doi: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2018.10.015. Epub 2018 Oct 26.
It is accepted in industries that an industrial helmet should be disposed of when it is subjected to a significant impact. There is no scientific evidence that supports this well-accepted belief. The current study was intended to evaluate the shock absorption performance of industrial helmets under repeated impacts. Common industrial or construction helmets are categorized as Type I according to ANSI Z89.1 and they are designed to mainly protect top impacts. A representative basic Type I construction helmet model was selected in the study. Helmets were repeatedly impacted ten times using a commercial drop tower tester with an impactor (mass 3.6 kg) at different drop heights from 0.30 to 2.03 m. A total of 80 impact trials were performed in the study. The relationships of the transmitted force with the drop height and with impact number were analyzed. A new parameter - the endurance limit - was proposed to evaluate the shock absorption performance of a helmet. The helmets were observed to experience cumulative structural damage with increasing impact number, resulting in a degrading shock absorption performance, when being impacted repeatedly with magnitudes greater than the endurance limit. Repeated impacts with magnitudes smaller than the endurance limit did not cause measurable cumulative structural damage to the helmets in our study.
在工业领域,人们普遍认为,工业安全帽在遭受重大撞击后就应予以丢弃。然而,目前尚无科学证据支持这一被广泛接受的观点。本研究旨在评估工业安全帽在反复撞击下的减震性能。根据美国国家标准学会(ANSI)Z89.1标准,常见的工业或建筑安全帽被归类为I型,其设计主要用于防护顶部撞击。本研究选取了一款具有代表性的基本I型建筑安全帽模型。使用商用落锤试验机,让质量为3.6千克的冲击器在0.30至2.03米的不同落高下,对安全帽进行十次反复撞击。本研究共进行了80次冲击试验。分析了传递力与落高以及与冲击次数之间的关系。提出了一个新参数——耐力极限,以评估安全帽的减震性能。研究发现,当安全帽受到大于耐力极限的反复撞击时,随着冲击次数的增加,会出现累积结构损伤,导致减震性能下降。在我们的研究中,受到小于耐力极限的反复撞击并未对安全帽造成可测量的累积结构损伤。