Sidman M, Kirk B, Willson-Morris M
J Exp Anal Behav. 1985 Jan;43(1):21-42. doi: 10.1901/jeab.1985.43-21.
In conditional-discrimination procedures with three sets of stimuli, A, B, and C, three stimuli per set (A1A2A3, B1B2B3, and C1C2C3), subjects (children and adults) learned to select Set-B and Set-C comparisons conditionally upon Set-A samples (A1B1, A1C1, A2B2, A2C2, A3B3, A3C3). If the conditional-discrimination procedures also generated equivalence relations, three 3-member stimulus classes would be demonstrable, A1B1C1, A2B2C2, and A3B3C3. In addition to these three sets, the present experiments used three other sets of stimuli--D, E, and F. The subjects learned to select Set-E and Set-F comparisons conditionally upon Set-D samples (D1E1, D1F1, D2E2, D2F2, D3E3, D3F3). This established a second group of three 3-member stimulus classes, D1E1F1, D2E2F2, and D3E3F3. In all, two groups of three 3-member classes were established by teaching subjects 12 conditional discriminations. The two groups of 3-member classes were then combined (successfully for 5 of 8 subjects) into a single group of three 6-member classes by teaching the subjects three more conditional relations (E1C1, E2C2, and E3C3). With three other children, enlarging the classes one member at a time also produced 6-member classes. As a consequence of class formation, 60 untrained conditional relations emerged from 15 that had been explicitly taught. Six of the subjects also proved capable of naming the stimuli consistently in accord with their class membership, but two subjects demonstrated class formation even in the absence of consistent naming.
在具有三组刺激(A、B和C)的条件辨别程序中,每组有三个刺激(A1A2A3、B1B2B3和C1C2C3),被试(儿童和成人)学会根据A组样本(A1B1、A1C1、A2B2、A2C2、A3B3、A3C3)有条件地选择B组和C组的比较刺激。如果条件辨别程序也产生了等价关系,那么三个由三个成员组成的刺激类将是可证明的,即A1B1C1、A2B2C2和A3B3C3。除了这三组刺激外,本实验还使用了另外三组刺激——D、E和F。被试学会根据D组样本(D1E1、D1F1、D2E2、D2F2、D3E3、D3F3)有条件地选择E组和F组的比较刺激。这建立了第二组由三个成员组成的刺激类,即D1E1F1、D2E2F2和D3E3F3。总共,通过教被试12种条件辨别建立了两组由三个成员组成的类。然后,通过教被试另外三种条件关系(E1C1、E2C2和E3C3),将这两组由三个成员组成的类(8名被试中有5名成功)组合成一组由三个六个成员组成的类。对于另外三名儿童,每次将类扩大一个成员也产生了六个成员的类。作为类形成的结果,从明确教过的15种条件关系中出现了60种未训练的条件关系。六名被试还证明能够根据刺激所属的类一致地命名刺激,但两名被试即使在没有一致命名的情况下也表现出类的形成。