From Hearing and Speech Sciences (S.K.D., A.M., M.d.R.), Biostatistics (Y.-C.L.), and Neurology (J.S., K.M., D.O.C.), Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN.
Neurology. 2019 Nov 26;93(22):e2042-e2052. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000008541. Epub 2019 Oct 29.
Dysarthric speech of persons with Huntington disease (HD) is typically described as hyperkinetic; however, studies suggest that dysarthria can vary and resemble patterns in other neurologic conditions. To test the hypothesis that distinct motor speech subgroups can be identified within a larger cohort of patients with HD, we performed a cluster analysis on speech perceptual characteristics of patient audio recordings.
Audio recordings of 48 patients with mild to moderate dysarthria due to HD were presented to 6 trained raters. Raters provided scores for various speech features (e.g., voice, articulation, prosody) of audio recordings using the classic Mayo Clinic dysarthria rating scale. Scores were submitted to an unsupervised k-means cluster analysis to determine the most salient speech features of subgroups based on motor speech patterns.
Four unique subgroups emerged from the cohort of patients with HD. Subgroup 1 was characterized by an abnormally fast speaking rate among other unique speech features, whereas subgroups 2 and 3 were defined by an abnormally slow speaking rate. Salient speech features for subgroup 2 overlapped with subgroup 3; however, the severity of dysarthria differed. Subgroup 4 was characterized by mild deviations of speech features with typical speech rate. Length of CAG repeats, Unified Huntington's Disease Rating Scale total motor score, and percent intelligibility were significantly different for pairwise comparisons of subgroups.
This study supports the existence of distinct presentations of dysarthria in patients with HD, which may be due to divergent pathologic processes. The findings are discussed in relation to previous literature and clinical implications.
亨廷顿病(HD)患者的构音障碍语音通常被描述为多动的;然而,研究表明构音障碍可能存在差异,并类似于其他神经疾病的模式。为了检验在更大的 HD 患者队列中可以识别出不同的运动言语亚组的假设,我们对患者音频记录的言语感知特征进行了聚类分析。
48 名轻度至中度构音障碍的 HD 患者的音频记录呈现给 6 名经过培训的评估员。评估员使用经典的 Mayo 诊所构音障碍评定量表为音频记录的各种言语特征(例如,声音、发音、韵律)提供评分。评分被提交给无监督的 k-均值聚类分析,以根据运动言语模式确定亚组的最显著言语特征。
HD 患者队列中出现了四个独特的亚组。亚组 1 的特征是说话速度异常快,其他独特的言语特征,而亚组 2 和 3 则以异常缓慢的说话速度为特征。亚组 2 的显著言语特征与亚组 3 重叠;然而,构音障碍的严重程度不同。亚组 4 的特点是言语特征有轻微偏差,言语速度正常。亚组间比较,CAG 重复次数、统一亨廷顿病评定量表总运动评分和可理解度百分比有显著差异。
本研究支持 HD 患者存在不同的构音障碍表现,这可能是由于不同的病理过程所致。研究结果与先前的文献和临床意义进行了讨论。