Valame Deepa A, Gore Geeta B
Department of Audiology and Speech Therapy, T.N. Medical College & B.Y.L. Nair Hospital, Dr A. Nair Road, Mumbai Central, Mumbai, Maharashtra 400008 India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2019 Oct;71(Suppl 1):425-433. doi: 10.1007/s12070-018-1335-2. Epub 2018 May 27.
Diagnosis of Meniere's disease is mainly clinical although many tests have been studied for efficacy in diagnosis of Meniere's disease. Glycerol test is a functional test to identify hydrops in Meniere's disease and can be done with PTA, Speech audiometry, otoacoustic emission, EcochG and cVEMP as its outcome measures. The study aimed to compare two outcome measures of glycerol test to identify Meniere's disease; to determine whether the stage of Meniere's disease affected glycerol outcomes; and to attempt to identify independent variables that could predict outcomes of glycerol test. 26 ears of 20 Meniere's disease participants were evaluated using PTA-based and cVEMP-based glycerol tests. Each test identified ten of 26 ears with Meniere's disease; and high agreement was noted in the two outcome measures. The stage of Meniere's disease based on four frequency hearing threshold average was not associated with outcome of glycerol test, but staging of Meniere's disease based on symptom duration was associated with glycerol test results. As the duration of symptoms increased there was lesser chance of positive outcomes on glycerol test; but intermediate stages of Meniere's disease showed positive outcomes. Variables such as age, gender, severity of hearing loss, duration of symptoms and pre-glycerol cVEMP measurements could not predict glycerol test outcomes. PTA-based and cVEMP- based glycerol tests hold promise in the test battery for identification of Meniere's disease. Positive findings on the test lead to confirmatory diagnosis but a negative glycerol test does not rule out Meniere's disease.
梅尼埃病的诊断主要基于临床症状,尽管已经有许多测试用于评估其诊断效果。甘油试验是一种用于识别梅尼埃病中耳积水的功能测试,可以通过纯音听阈测试(PTA)、言语测听、耳声发射、耳蜗电图(EcochG)和颈肌源性电位(cVEMP)作为其结果指标。本研究旨在比较甘油试验的两种结果指标以识别梅尼埃病;确定梅尼埃病的阶段是否会影响甘油试验结果;并尝试识别可预测甘油试验结果的独立变量。对20名梅尼埃病患者的26只耳朵进行了基于PTA和基于cVEMP的甘油试验评估。每种测试都在26只患有梅尼埃病的耳朵中识别出了10只;并且在两种结果指标中发现了高度一致性。基于四个频率听力阈值平均值的梅尼埃病阶段与甘油试验结果无关,但基于症状持续时间的梅尼埃病分期与甘油试验结果相关。随着症状持续时间的增加,甘油试验呈阳性结果的可能性降低;但梅尼埃病的中期阶段显示出阳性结果。年龄、性别、听力损失严重程度症状持续时间和甘油试验前的cVEMP测量等变量无法预测甘油试验结果。基于PTA和基于cVEMP的甘油试验在用于识别梅尼埃病的测试组合中具有前景。测试中的阳性结果可导致确诊,但甘油试验阴性并不能排除梅尼埃病。