Research and Education Service, Clinical Epidemiology Center, Veterans Affairs St Louis Health Care System, St Louis, Missouri.
College for Public Health and Social Justice, Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, St Louis University, St Louis, Missouri.
JAMA Netw Open. 2019 Nov 1;2(11):e1915834. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.15834.
Ambient fine particulate matter (PM2.5) air pollution is associated with increased risk of several causes of death. However, epidemiologic evidence suggests that current knowledge does not comprehensively capture all causes of death associated with PM2.5 exposure.
To systematically identify causes of death associated with PM2.5 pollution and estimate the burden of death for each cause in the United States.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In a cohort study of US veterans followed up between 2006 and 2016, ensemble modeling was used to identify and characterize morphology of the association between PM2.5 and causes of death. Burden of death associated with PM2.5 exposure in the contiguous United States and for each state was then estimated by application of estimated risk functions to county-level PM2.5 estimates from the US Environmental Protection Agency and cause-specific death rate data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Nonlinear exposure-response functions of the association between PM2.5 and causes of death and burden of death associated with PM2.5.
Annual mean PM2.5 levels.
A cohort of 4 522 160 US veterans (4 243 462 [93.8%] male; median [interquartile range] age, 64.1 [55.7-75.5] years; 3 702 942 [82.0%] white, 667 550 [14.8%] black, and 145 593 [3.2%] other race) was followed up for a median (interquartile range) of 10.0 (6.8-10.2) years. In the contiguous United States, PM2.5 exposure was associated with excess burden of death due to cardiovascular disease (56 070.1 deaths [95% uncertainty interval {UI}, 51 940.2-60 318.3 deaths]), cerebrovascular disease (40 466.1 deaths [95% UI, 21 770.1-46 487.9 deaths]), chronic kidney disease (7175.2 deaths [95% UI, 5910.2-8371.9 deaths]), chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (645.7 deaths [95% UI, 300.2-2490.9 deaths]), dementia (19 851.5 deaths [95% UI, 14 420.6-31 621.4 deaths]), type 2 diabetes (501.3 deaths [95% UI, 447.5-561.1 deaths]), hypertension (30 696.9 deaths [95% UI, 27 518.1-33 881.9 deaths]), lung cancer (17 545.3 deaths [95% UI, 15 055.3-20 464.5 deaths]), and pneumonia (8854.9 deaths [95% UI, 7696.2-10 710.6 deaths]). Burden exhibited substantial geographic variation. Estimated burden of death due to nonaccidental causes was 197 905.1 deaths (95% UI, 183 463.3-213 644.9 deaths); mean age-standardized death rates (per 100 000) due to nonaccidental causes were higher among black individuals (55.2 [95% UI, 50.5-60.6]) than nonblack individuals (51.0 [95% UI, 46.4-56.1]) and higher among those living in counties with high (65.3 [95% UI, 56.2-75.4]) vs low (46.1 [95% UI, 42.3-50.4]) socioeconomic deprivation; 99.0% of the burden of death due to nonaccidental causes was associated with PM2.5 levels below standards set by the US Environmental Protection Agency.
In this study, 9 causes of death were associated with PM2.5 exposure. The burden of death associated with PM2.5 was disproportionally borne by black individuals and socioeconomically disadvantaged communities. Effort toward cleaner air might reduce the burden of PM2.5-associated deaths.
重要性:环境细颗粒物(PM2.5)空气污染与多种死因的风险增加有关。然而,流行病学证据表明,目前的知识并没有全面涵盖与 PM2.5 暴露相关的所有死因。
目的:系统地确定与 PM2.5 污染相关的死因,并估计美国每种死因的死亡负担。
设计、地点和参与者:在一项对美国退伍军人进行的队列研究中,参与者在 2006 年至 2016 年期间进行了随访,该研究使用集合建模来识别和描述 PM2.5 与死因之间关联的形态。然后,通过将估计的风险函数应用于美国环境保护署的县级 PM2.5 估计值和疾病控制与预防中心的特定死因死亡率数据,估计了与 PM2.5 暴露相关的死亡负担。
主要结果和措施:PM2.5 与死因之间的关联的非线性暴露-反应函数以及与 PM2.5 相关的死亡负担。
暴露:每年平均 PM2.5 水平。
结果:在一项由 4522160 名美国退伍军人组成的队列研究中(4243462 名男性[93.8%];中位[四分位间距]年龄,64.1[55.7-75.5]岁;3702942 名白人[82.0%],667550 名黑人[14.8%]和 145593 名其他种族[3.2%]),中位(四分位间距)随访时间为 10.0(6.8-10.2)年。在美国,PM2.5 暴露与心血管疾病(56070.1 例死亡[95%不确定性区间{UI},51940.2-60318.3 例死亡])、脑血管疾病(40466.1 例死亡[95%UI,21770.1-46487.9 例死亡])、慢性肾脏病(7175.2 例死亡[95%UI,5910.2-8371.9 例死亡])、慢性阻塞性肺疾病(645.7 例死亡[95%UI,300.2-2490.9 例死亡])、痴呆(19851.5 例死亡[95%UI,14420.6-31621.4 例死亡])、2 型糖尿病(501.3 例死亡[95%UI,447.5-561.1 例死亡])、高血压(30696.9 例死亡[95%UI,27518.1-33881.9 例死亡])、肺癌(17545.3 例死亡[95%UI,15055.3-20464.5 例死亡])和肺炎(8854.9 例死亡[95%UI,7696.2-10710.6 例死亡])导致的死亡负担过高。负担表现出显著的地域差异。非意外原因导致的死亡负担估计为 197905.1 例死亡(95%UI,183463.3-213644.9 例死亡);非意外原因导致的平均年龄标准化死亡率(每 10 万人)在黑人中较高(55.2[95%UI,50.5-60.6])而非黑人中较低(51.0[95%UI,46.4-56.1]),并且在经济社会地位较低的县中较高(65.3[95%UI,56.2-75.4])与经济社会地位较高的县(46.1[95%UI,42.3-50.4]);与非意外原因相关的死亡负担的 99.0%与美国环境保护署设定的 PM2.5 标准以下的水平有关。
结论和相关性:在这项研究中,有 9 种死因与 PM2.5 暴露有关。与 PM2.5 暴露相关的死亡负担不成比例地由黑人个体和社会经济劣势社区承担。为改善空气质量而进行的努力可能会降低与 PM2.5 相关的死亡人数。