McDonald A D, McDonald J C, Armstrong B, Cherry N M, Côté R, Lavoie J, Nolin A D, Robert D
Institut de Recherche en Santé et en Sécurité du Travail du Québec, Montreal, Canada.
Br J Ind Med. 1988 Sep;45(9):581-8. doi: 10.1136/oem.45.9.581.
The risk of congenital defect was examined in 47,913 pregnancies of women employed for 15 hours a week or more at time of conception. The rate of defects of all types per 1000 births in this series was 25.0; 1.8 from defects classified as chromosomal (group A), 10.8 as developmental (group B), and 12.5 as musculoskeletal (group C). Some evidence of an excess in the risk ratio (p less than 0.05) was found in the services sector and in four occupations--agriculture and horticulture (2.61), telephone and postal clerks (1.74), a miscellaneous group of service jobs (1.68), and receptionists and information clerks (1.47); excesses of lower statistical significance (p less than 0.1) were found in those engaged in plastics and rubber manufacture (2.02) and in child minders (1.84). There were two cases of tracheo-oesophageal fistula--a rare defect--among eight defects (1.32 expected) in agriculture and horticulture. Overall, the distribution of risk ratios in the 60 occupations examined was not significantly heterogeneous. Analysis of chemical exposure profiles for each occupational group showed no evidence of any increased risk, perhaps due to lack of sensitivity and discrimination in this method of exposure estimation. In 152 pregnancies of doctors and nurses who had administered antineoplastic drugs in the first month eight defects, miscellaneous in type, were observed compared with 4.05 expected (p = 0.05). Special study of musculoskeletal defects and work demands showed some evidence of an association with a long working week (greater than or equal to 46 hours) but no other ergonomic factor. With these few exceptions the survey failed to identify appreciable risk of congenital defect related to occupation.
对47913名在怀孕时每周工作15小时及以上的职业女性的妊娠情况进行了先天性缺陷风险检查。该系列中每1000例出生的各类缺陷发生率为25.0;染色体缺陷(A组)为1.8,发育性缺陷(B组)为10.8,肌肉骨骼缺陷(C组)为12.5。在服务业和四个职业中发现了风险比过高的一些证据(p小于0.05)——农业和园艺业(2.61)、电话和邮政职员(1.74)、一组杂项服务工作(1.68)以及接待员和信息员(1.47);在从事塑料和橡胶制造的人员(2.02)以及儿童保育员(1.84)中发现了统计学显著性较低(p小于0.1)的过高风险。在农业和园艺业的8例缺陷(预期为1.32例)中有2例气管食管瘘——一种罕见缺陷。总体而言,在所检查的60种职业中,风险比的分布没有显著的异质性。对每个职业组的化学暴露情况分析未显示任何风险增加的证据,这可能是由于这种暴露估计方法缺乏敏感性和区分度。在152例医生和护士在妊娠第一个月使用过抗肿瘤药物的妊娠中,观察到8例各类缺陷,而预期为4.05例(p = 0.05)。对肌肉骨骼缺陷和工作要求的专项研究显示,有一些证据表明与长工作周(大于或等于46小时)有关,但与其他人体工程学因素无关。除了这些少数例外情况,该调查未能确定与职业相关的明显先天性缺陷风险。