Centre for Medical Education, School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences, Queen's University Belfast, Whitla Medical Building, 97 Lisburn Road,, Belfast, BT9 7BL, Northern Ireland.
School of Clinical Medicine, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
J Cancer Educ. 2020 Aug;35(4):643-650. doi: 10.1007/s13187-019-01647-7.
In many countries, patients with concerning skin lesions will first consult a primary care physician (PCP). Dermoscopy has an evidence base supporting its use in primary care for skin cancer detection, but need for training has been cited as a key barrier to its use. How PCPs train to use dermoscopy is unclear. A scoping literature review was carried out to examine what is known from the published literature about PCP training in dermoscopy. The methodological steps taken in this review followed those described by Arksey and O'Malley, as revised by Levac et al. Four electronic databases were searched for evidence published up to June 2018. Sixteen articles were identified for analysis, all published since 2000. Ten training programs were identified all of which addressed dermoscopy of pigmented skin lesions, among other topics. Ten articles reported on a range of outcomes measured after training and showed generally positive results in terms of improved diagnostic performance, although no meta-analysis was conducted. However, it was unclear whether trained PCPs continued to use dermoscopy after training. Observational questionnaire data revealed that many PCPs use dermoscopy in practice without any formal training. The literature generally supports the use of dermoscopy by PCPs, but it is unclear whether current training leads to long-term change in PCPs' use of dermoscopy in clinical practice. Understanding this problem, as well as exploring PCPs' training needs, is essential to develop training programs that will facilitate the uptake and use of dermoscopy in primary care.
在许多国家,有可疑皮肤病变的患者通常会先咨询初级保健医生(PCP)。皮肤镜检查有证据支持其在初级保健中用于皮肤癌检测,但需要培训已被认为是其使用的主要障碍。PCP 如何接受皮肤镜检查培训尚不清楚。进行了一项范围广泛的文献综述,以检查已发表文献中关于 PCP 皮肤镜检查培训的知识。本综述所采取的方法步骤遵循了 Arksey 和 O'Malley 的描述,并由 Levac 等人修订。共在四个电子数据库中搜索了截至 2018 年 6 月发表的证据。确定了 16 篇文章进行分析,这些文章均发表于 2000 年以后。确定了 10 个培训计划,其中都涉及色素性皮肤病变的皮肤镜检查等内容。有 10 篇文章报告了培训后的一系列结果,结果显示在提高诊断性能方面通常取得了积极的效果,尽管没有进行荟萃分析。但是,尚不清楚接受培训的 PCP 是否在培训后继续使用皮肤镜检查。观察性问卷调查数据显示,许多 PCP 在实践中使用皮肤镜检查,但没有接受任何正式培训。文献普遍支持 PCP 使用皮肤镜检查,但尚不清楚当前的培训是否会导致 PCP 在临床实践中长期改变皮肤镜检查的使用。了解这一问题,并探索 PCP 的培训需求,对于开发培训计划以促进皮肤镜检查在初级保健中的应用至关重要。