Division Neuropsychology, Department of Psychology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Division Neuropsychology, Department of Psychology, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Neuroimage. 2020 Aug 1;216:116513. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2019.116513. Epub 2019 Dec 31.
Previous studies have reported the effects of absolute pitch (AP) and musical proficiency on the functioning of specific brain regions or distinct subnetworks, but they provided an incomplete account of the effects of AP and musical proficiency on whole-brain networks. In this study, we used EEG to estimate source-space whole-brain functional connectivity in a large sample comprising AP musicians (n = 46), relative pitch (RP) musicians (n = 45), and Non-musicians (n = 34) during resting state, naturalistic music listening, and audiobook listening. First, we assessed the global network density of the participants' functional networks in these conditions. As revealed by cluster-based permutation testing, AP musicians showed a decreased mean degree compared to Non-musicians whereas RP musicians showed an intermediate mean degree not statistically different from Non-musicians or AP-musicians. This effect was present during naturalistic music and audiobook listening, but, crucially, not during resting state. Second, we identified the subnetworks that drove group differences in global network density using the network-based statistic approach. We found that AP musicians showed decreased functional connectivity between major hubs of the default mode network during both music and audiobook listening compared to Non-musicians. Third, we assessed group differences in global network topology while controlling for network density. We did not find evidence for group differences in the clustering coefficient and characteristic path length. Taken together, we found first evidence of diminished whole-brain functional networks in AP musicians during the perception of naturalistic auditory stimuli. These differences might reflect a complex interplay between AP ability, musical proficiency, music processing, and auditory processing per se.
先前的研究报告了绝对音高 (AP) 和音乐能力对特定脑区或不同子网功能的影响,但它们并没有完整描述 AP 和音乐能力对全脑网络的影响。在这项研究中,我们使用 EEG 来估计包括 AP 音乐家 (n = 46)、相对音高 (RP) 音乐家 (n = 45) 和非音乐家 (n = 34) 在内的大样本在静息状态、自然音乐聆听和有声读物聆听期间的源空间全脑功能连接。首先,我们评估了参与者在这些条件下功能网络的全局网络密度。通过基于聚类的置换检验发现,AP 音乐家的平均度低于非音乐家,而 RP 音乐家的平均度处于中间,与非音乐家或 AP 音乐家没有统计学差异。这种效应存在于自然音乐和有声读物聆听期间,但至关重要的是,在静息状态期间不存在。其次,我们使用基于网络的统计方法识别了导致全局网络密度组间差异的子网。我们发现,与非音乐家相比,AP 音乐家在聆听音乐和有声读物时,默认模式网络的主要枢纽之间的功能连接减少。第三,我们在控制网络密度的情况下评估了全局网络拓扑的组间差异。我们没有发现组间聚类系数和特征路径长度存在差异的证据。综上所述,我们首次发现,AP 音乐家在感知自然听觉刺激时,全脑功能网络减少。这些差异可能反映了 AP 能力、音乐能力、音乐处理和听觉处理本身之间的复杂相互作用。