Watts Paul, Rance Susanna, McGowan Victoria, Brown Heather, Bambra Clare, Findlay Gail, Harden Angela
1School of Health, Sport and Bioscience, College of Applied Health and Communities, University of East London, Stratford Campus, Water Lane, London, E15 4LZ UK.
2Institute for Health and Human Development, University of East London, Stratford Campus, Water Lane, London, E15 4LZ UK.
Pilot Feasibility Stud. 2020 Jan 10;6:4. doi: 10.1186/s40814-020-0550-2. eCollection 2020.
Increasing levels of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), mental health problems, high rates of unhealthy behaviours and health inequalities remain major public health challenges worldwide. In the context of increasing urbanisation, there is an urgent need to understand how evidence that living environments shape health, wellbeing and behaviour can be used to design and deliver healthy environments in local urban settings. The Healthy New Town (HNT) programme implemented in England from 2015 consists of ten major housing developments that aim to improve population health through healthy design principles, new models for integrating health and social care and the creation of strong and connected communities. The programme provides a natural experiment in which to investigate the effects on health, wellbeing and inequalities of large-scale interventions targeting the wider social determinants of health.
The research described in this protocol aims to examine the feasibility of a larger study to assess the longer-term health impacts of HNTs, by addressing two research questions: (1) what are the similarities and differences in the HNT programme developments, processes, contexts and expected impacts and outcomes across HNT sites? and (2) how feasible is the use of data from routine sources and existing HNT evaluations and as the baseline for a definitive study to assess impact on health, wellbeing, behavioural and economic outcomes and programme processes? The research will consist of (a) participatory systems mapping with stakeholders to produce a theoretical framework for a longer-term study on the HNT programme, (b) synthesis of existing qualitative data from local HNT evaluations to understand local processes and intervention mechanisms, (c) scoping local and routinely available data to establish a baseline and feasibility for a longer-term study of health and economic outcomes, and (d) building relationships and recruiting HNT sites into the proposed research.
The proposed research will produce a theoretical framework and assess the feasibility of a definitive study of outcomes of the HNT programme. This research is necessary to understand how longer-term health, wellbeing, behavioural and economic outcomes can be measured, and to inform a definitive study to generate evidence on the effectiveness of the HNT programme.
非传染性疾病(NCDs)水平不断上升、心理健康问题、不健康行为的高发生率以及健康不平等现象仍是全球主要的公共卫生挑战。在城市化进程不断加快的背景下,迫切需要了解生活环境如何塑造健康、福祉和行为的相关证据,以便在当地城市环境中用于设计和打造健康环境。2015年起在英格兰实施的健康新镇(HNT)计划由十个大型住房开发项目组成,旨在通过健康设计原则、整合健康与社会护理的新模式以及创建强大且相互联系的社区来改善人口健康状况。该计划提供了一个自然实验,用以研究针对更广泛健康社会决定因素的大规模干预措施对健康、福祉和不平等现象的影响。
本方案中描述的研究旨在通过解决两个研究问题来检验一项更大规模研究的可行性,该研究旨在评估健康新镇的长期健康影响:(1)健康新镇计划在各个健康新镇地点的发展、过程、背景以及预期影响和成果有哪些异同?(2)使用常规来源数据和现有健康新镇评估数据作为确定性研究的基线,以评估对健康、福祉、行为和经济成果以及计划过程的影响,可行性如何?该研究将包括:(a)与利益相关者进行参与式系统映射,以生成关于健康新镇计划的长期研究的理论框架;(b)综合当地健康新镇评估中的现有定性数据,以了解当地过程和干预机制;(c)梳理当地和常规可得数据,为健康和经济成果的长期研究建立基线和可行性;(d)建立关系并招募健康新镇地点参与拟议的研究。
拟议的研究将产生一个理论框架,并评估对健康新镇计划成果进行确定性研究的可行性。这项研究对于了解如何衡量长期健康、福祉、行为和经济成果以及为确定性研究提供信息以生成关于健康新镇计划有效性的证据是必要的。