Lysenko-Martin Melanie R, Hutton Craig P, Sparks Taya, Snowden Taylor, Christie Brian R
Division of Medical Sciences, University of Victoria, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
J Neurotrauma. 2020 Aug 15;37(16):1777-1787. doi: 10.1089/neu.2019.6842. Epub 2020 Apr 17.
The diagnosis of concussion remains challenging, particularly in cases where several months have passed between a traumatic brain injury (TBI) and clinical assessment. Tracking multiple moving objects in three-dimensional (3D) space engages many of the same cognitive processes that are affected by concussion, a form of mild TBI (mTBI), suggesting that tests of 3D multiple object tracking (3D-MOT) may be sensitive to post-concussion syndrome (PCS) after a brain injury has occurred. To test this, we evaluated 3D-MOT performance (using NeuroTracker) against Sports Concussion Assessment Tool results for cognition, balance, and symptom severity in a large sample ( = 457) of male and female participants between the ages of 6 and 73 years. 3D-MOT performance in subjects under age 13 was not impaired by a history of concussion, but was positively associated with cognition and balance. 3D-MOT performance in those 13 and older was negatively associated with concussion symptom severity and positively associated with cognition and balance. 3D-MOT was selectively impaired in subjects with probable PCS (pPCS), defined using the 95th percentile of symptom severity for subjects with no history of concussion. A decision tree predicted concussion status with 95.2% overall test accuracy (91.1% sensitivity, 97.8% specificity), using concussion history, age, and 3D-MOT score. Persons with a history of concussion in the past 37 days were predicted to have pPCS if they were ≥35 years of age, or if they were <35 years of age but achieved scores below 1.2 on the 3D-MOT. These results demonstrate the potential of 3D-MOT for pPCS diagnosis and highlight the increased vulnerability to concussion symptoms that comes with age.
脑震荡的诊断仍然具有挑战性,尤其是在创伤性脑损伤(TBI)与临床评估之间间隔数月的情况下。在三维(3D)空间中追踪多个移动物体涉及许多与脑震荡(一种轻度TBI,即mTBI)所影响的相同认知过程,这表明3D多物体追踪(3D-MOT)测试可能对脑损伤后出现的脑震荡后综合征(PCS)敏感。为了验证这一点,我们针对年龄在6至73岁之间的大量男女参与者(n = 457),根据运动性脑震荡评估工具对认知、平衡和症状严重程度的评估结果,对3D-MOT表现(使用NeuroTracker)进行了评估。13岁以下受试者的3D-MOT表现不受脑震荡病史的影响,但与认知和平衡呈正相关。13岁及以上受试者的3D-MOT表现与脑震荡症状严重程度呈负相关,与认知和平衡呈正相关。在使用无脑震荡病史受试者症状严重程度第95百分位数定义的可能患有PCS(pPCS)的受试者中,3D-MOT表现存在选择性受损。使用脑震荡病史、年龄和3D-MOT分数的决策树预测脑震荡状态的总体测试准确率为95.2%(敏感性为91.1%,特异性为97.8%)。如果过去37天内有脑震荡病史的人年龄≥35岁,或者年龄<35岁但3D-MOT得分低于1.2,则预测其患有pPCS。这些结果证明了3D-MOT在诊断pPCS方面的潜力,并突出了随着年龄增长脑震荡症状易感性增加的情况。