Department of Pharmacy, Clinical Pharmacy Unit, Ambo University, Ambo, Ethiopia.
Department of Pharmacy, Pharmacology Unit, Ambo University, Ambo, Ethiopia.
PLoS One. 2020 Jan 21;15(1):e0227858. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0227858. eCollection 2020.
Health-related quality of life (HRQOL) is used as a measure of treatment outcomes, in addition to seizure control. Hence, the study was aimed to assess HRQOL and its determinants among adult patients with epilepsy (PWE).
A hospital-based cross-sectional study was conducted from April 20 to June 27/2019, through patient interviews and patient's chart review (medication and clinical information). Data were analyzed using SPSS version 20. The psychometric property was done using Cronbach's alpha test value of >0.7 as accepted internal consistency and Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) measure of sample size adequacy value of ≥0.5 as acceptable construct validity, for Afaan Oromo version questionnaire. Multivariate linear logistic regression analysis was done to find predictors for the HRQOL score.
Of 121 PWE included in the study, 24.4% had overall poor HRQOL with the overall mean ±SD score of 56.42±10.96. The predictors for low overall HRQOL score were: presence of co-morbidity (B = -5.620, SE = 1.531, p<0.0001, 95% C.I = -8.656 to -2.584), uncontrolled seizure for at least 2 years (B = -4.239, SE = 1.296, p = 0.001, 95% C.I = -6.809 to -1.670), divorced (B = -8.423, SE = 2.241, p<0.0001, 95%C.I = -12.867 to -3.978) relative to married, and no education (B = -8.715, SE = -8.15, SE = 2.604, p = 0.001, 95%C.I = -9.648 to -1.316) relative to who had level of education above tertiary. In addition, uncontrolled seizure (irrespective of time since seizure-free) (B = -10.083, SE = 2.104, p<0.0001, 95%C.I = -14.256 to -5.910), being widowed (B = -9.300, SE = 3.594, p = 0.011, 95%C.I = -16.429-2.170) relative to married and being illiterate/no education (B = -13.004, SE = 3.910, p = 0.001, 95%C.I = -20.760 to -5.248) relative to educational level of tertiary and above were found to be the strongest negative predictors of HRQOL of physical health. Moreover, uncontrolled seizure (irrespective of time since seizure-free) (B = -12.668, SE = 2.019, p<0.0001, 95%C.I = -16.671 to -8.664) and being divorced (B = -10.153, SE = 3.228, p = 0.002, 95%C.I = -16.556 to -3.751) compared to married were strong predictors for low HRQOL score of psychological health. Absence of Poly-pharmacy (B = 9.050, SE = 3.027, P = 0.003, 95%C.I = 3.047 to 15.054), being single (B = -9.551, SE = 2.095, p<0.0001, 95%C.I = -14.419 to -4.683), and divorced (B = -11.022, SE = 3.351, P = 0.001, 95%C.I = -17.668 to -4.376) relative to married were found to be strong predictors for HRQOL score of social health. Moreover, low HRQOL score of environmental health was predicted by rural residence (B = -5.795, SE = 2.101, p = 0.007, 95%C.I = -9.962 to -1.628), co-morbidity (B+ -4.230, SE = 2.125, p = 0.049, 95%C.I = -8.444 to -0.015) & uncontrolled seizure irrespective of time since seizure-free (B = -6.907, SE = 1.945, p = 0.001, 95%C.I = -10.765 to -3.049) and uncontrolled seizure of at least 2 years (B = -4.520, SE = 1.798, p = 0.014, 95%C.I = -8.088 to -0.953).
The majority of the study participants had a good overall HRQOL. In general, a low level of HRQOL score was significantly associated with the marital status of single/widowed/divorced, low level of education, low level of monthly income, co-morbidity, uncontrolled seizure, and poly-pharmacy; irrespective of HRQOL domains. Therefore, it is required to improve HRQOL, by avoiding modifiable factors for PWE to achieve the optimum HRQOL.
健康相关生活质量 (HRQOL) 除了控制癫痫发作外,还被用作治疗效果的衡量标准。因此,本研究旨在评估成年癫痫患者 (PWE) 的 HRQOL 及其决定因素。
采用基于医院的横断面研究,于 2019 年 4 月 20 日至 6 月 27 日进行,通过患者访谈和患者病历回顾(药物和临床信息)。使用 SPSS 版本 20 分析数据。使用 Cronbach's alpha 测试值>0.7 作为可接受的内部一致性和 Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin(KMO)样本大小充分性值≥0.5 作为可接受的结构有效性,对奥罗莫语问卷进行了心理计量特性测试。采用多元线性逻辑回归分析发现 HRQOL 评分的预测因子。
在纳入研究的 121 名 PWE 中,24.4%的患者整体 HRQOL 较差,整体平均得分±标准差为 56.42±10.96。整体 HRQOL 评分较低的预测因素包括:合并症(B = -5.620,SE = 1.531,p<0.0001,95%CI = -8.656 至 -2.584)、至少 2 年未控制的癫痫发作(B = -4.239,SE = 1.296,p = 0.001,95%CI = -6.809 至 -1.670)、离婚(B = -8.423,SE = 2.241,p<0.0001,95%C.I = -12.867 至 -3.978)与已婚相比,以及未接受教育(B = -8.715,SE = -8.15,SE = 2.604,p = 0.001,95%C.I = -9.648 至 -1.316)与接受过高等教育的人相比。此外,未控制的癫痫发作(无论癫痫无发作时间如何)(B = -10.083,SE = 2.104,p<0.0001,95%C.I = -14.256 至 -5.910)、丧偶(B = -9.300,SE = 3.594,p = 0.011,95%C.I = -16.429-2.170)与已婚相比,以及文盲/未接受教育(B = -13.004,SE = 3.910,p = 0.001,95%C.I = -20.760 至 -5.248)与接受过高等教育的人相比,是身体健康的 HRQOL 的最强负预测因子。此外,未控制的癫痫发作(无论癫痫无发作时间如何)(B = -12.668,SE = 2.019,p<0.0001,95%C.I = -16.671 至 -8.664)和离婚(B = -10.153,SE = 3.228,p = 0.002,95%C.I = -16.556 至 -3.751)与已婚相比,是心理健康 HRQOL 评分较低的强预测因子。无多药治疗(B = 9.050,SE = 3.027,P = 0.003,95%C.I = 3.047 至 15.054)、单身(B = -9.551,SE = 2.095,p<0.0001,95%C.I = -14.419 至 -4.683)和离婚(B = -11.022,SE = 3.351,P = 0.001,95%C.I = -17.668 至 -4.376)与已婚相比,是社会健康 HRQOL 评分的强预测因子。此外,农村居住(B = -5.795,SE = 2.101,p = 0.007,95%C.I = -9.962 至 -1.628)、合并症(B+ -4.230,SE = 2.125,p = 0.049,95%C.I = -8.444 至 -0.015)和无控制的癫痫发作,无论癫痫无发作时间如何(B = -6.907,SE = 1.945,p = 0.001,95%C.I = -10.765 至 -3.049)和至少 2 年无控制的癫痫发作(B = -4.520,SE = 1.798,p = 0.014,95%C.I = -8.088 至 -0.953)是环境健康的 HRQOL 评分较低的预测因素。
大多数研究参与者的整体 HRQOL 良好。一般来说,HRQOL 评分较低与单身/丧偶/离婚、低教育水平、低月收入、合并症、未控制的癫痫发作和多药治疗等婚姻状况显著相关;不论 HRQOL 领域如何。因此,需要改善 HRQOL,避免可改变的因素,以实现 PWE 的最佳 HRQOL。