Technical University Delft, PO Box 5015, 2600, GA, Delft, Netherlands.
BC Hydro, 6911 Southpoint Drive, Burnaby, BC, V3N 4X8, Canada.
Environ Res. 2020 Apr;183:109127. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2020.109127. Epub 2020 Jan 16.
Since Nassim Taleb coined black swan as an event that occurred as a complete surprise for everybody, the metaphor of the black swan has been applied to a much wider variety of events. Black swan events now comprise events that are a surprise for some but not for others, events that have a low likelihood, events that were not believed to be possible but still proved to be possible, events that were dismissed as being too improbable to worry about but happened anyway. For a decision maker the black swan problem is choosing where to put effort to prevent, or mitigate events for which there are warnings, or for which the possibility has been put forward. Does the fact that there are thousands of books written about fire breathing dragons warrant the development of an Anti-Dragon Defense Shield? The black swan may have been a surprise for Willem de Vlamingh in 1697, it was not a surprise for the inhabitants of Australia, for which the appearance of tall white humans was their "black swan event". In this paper we explore the options available to decision makers when confronted with the various sorts of swan (or dragon) events.
自纳西姆·塔勒布(Nassim Taleb)创造“黑天鹅”一词来形容完全出乎所有人意料的事件以来,这一隐喻已经被应用于更广泛的事件。现在,“黑天鹅”事件包括对某些人来说是意料之外的事件,但对其他人来说并非如此;低概率事件;原本被认为不可能发生但事实证明是可能的事件;被认为不太可能发生而无需担心但却发生了的事件。对于决策者来说,“黑天鹅”问题是要选择在哪里投入精力来预防或减轻有预警的事件,或者是针对那些可能性已经提出的事件。成千上万本关于喷火巨龙的书籍是否证明了需要开发一种“反龙防御盾牌”?1697 年,黑天鹅对威廉·德弗林格(Willem de Vlamingh)来说可能是一个惊喜,但对澳大利亚的居民来说却不是,因为高大的白人出现对他们来说是他们的“黑天鹅事件”。在本文中,我们探讨了当决策者面临各种“天鹅”(或“龙”)事件时可供选择的方案。