Bahloul Moez
Laboratoire de Recherche " Laboratoire des Sciences de l'Environnement et Développement Durable " (LASED) (LR18ES32), IPEI Sfax, University of Sfax, Tunisia , Cité Erriadh, Rue Riadh, Sfax, 3072 Sfax, Sfax Tunisia.
J Environ Health Sci Eng. 2020 Jan 8;17(2):1085-1105. doi: 10.1007/s40201-019-00423-5. eCollection 2019 Dec.
Concentrations of six heavy metals such as Fe, Pb, Cu, Cd, Ni and Zn in dry atmospheric deposits weekly collected through 20 sample sites from Sfax solar saltern during two successive sampling campaigns, selected from a long time monitoring, have been examined in order to evaluate their contamination levels as well as their human health risk; such concentrations (expressed in mg/kg) have shown that Fe varied from 7006.24 to 7856.45, Pb from 8.64 to 344.45, Cu from 9.33 to 298.67, Cd from 0.16 to 85.24, Ni from 6.02 to 150.02, and Zn from 12.23 to 624.57. During the study period, average concentrations (mg/kg) have been 7315.99, 103.08, 82.34, 15.93, 46.21 and 142.39, for Fe, Pb, Cu, Cd, Ni and Zn, respectively. Except for Fe, the other concentrations in dry atmospheric deposits have recorded the highest level during the first campaign especially in the sites which are close and more exposed to emissions of local pollutant industries, as well as nearby main road, resulting from high exposure frequencies. Statistical approaches, such as principal component analysis and hierarchical cluster analysis have been applied to all data, revealing an affinity between analyzed metals resulting from their origins, and confirming the influence of exposure frequencies on the spatial variability of heavy metal concentrations. Human health risk assessment has revealed that ingestion of heavy metals is the main exposure pathway for the local population. Computed Hazardous Quotient and Hazardous Index have been higher for children than for adults, thus indicating that the former may be subjected to potentially higher health risk than the latter especially during the first campaign. Calculated carcinogenic risks through ingestion and dermal contact, as well as the total carcinogenic risk for the selected heavy metals, have shown that cancer could occur more probably through ingestion than dermal contact, for children than adult, and during the first campaign (during C1: average values CRing = 8.72 × 10 and CRder = 1.40 × 10 for child; average values CRing = 5.61 × 10 and CRder = 2.84 × 10 for adult) than the second one (during C2: average values CRing = 1.59 × 10 and CRder = 2.54 × 10 for child; average values CRing = 1.02 × 10 and CRder = 5.19 × 10 for adult). The total calculated carcinogenic risk through all the sites have infrequently signaled high to very high carcinogenic risk in the first campaign (average CRA = 8.73 × 10 for child and CRA = 5.89 × 10 for adult) and occasionally exceeded the safe range for the local population in the second one (average CRA = 1.59 × 10 for child and CRA = 1.07 × 10 for adult).
在两次连续的采样活动中,通过从长期监测中选取的20个采样点,每周收集斯法克斯太阳能盐场的干燥大气沉积物,对其中铁(Fe)、铅(Pb)、铜(Cu)、镉(Cd)、镍(Ni)和锌(Zn)六种重金属的浓度进行了检测,以评估其污染水平及其对人类健康的风险;这些浓度(以mg/kg表示)表明,铁的浓度在7006.24至7856.45之间,铅在8.64至344.45之间,铜在9.33至298.67之间,镉在0.16至85.24之间,镍在6.02至150.02之间,锌在12.23至624.57之间。在研究期间,铁、铅、铜、镉、镍和锌的平均浓度(mg/kg)分别为7315.99、103.08、82.34、15.93、46.21和142.39。除铁外,干燥大气沉积物中的其他浓度在第一次采样活动期间达到最高水平,特别是在那些靠近且更易受到当地污染工业排放影响的地点,以及靠近主要道路的地点,这是由于高暴露频率所致。主成分分析和层次聚类分析等统计方法已应用于所有数据,揭示了所分析金属之间因其来源而存在的亲和力,并证实了暴露频率对重金属浓度空间变异性的影响。人类健康风险评估表明,重金属摄入是当地居民的主要暴露途径。计算得出的儿童危险商和危险指数高于成人,这表明前者可能比后者面临更高的潜在健康风险,尤其是在第一次采样活动期间。通过摄入和皮肤接触计算得出的致癌风险,以及所选重金属的总致癌风险表明,儿童比成人更可能通过摄入而非皮肤接触致癌,且在第一次采样活动期间(在C1期间:儿童的平均CRing值 = 8.72×10,CRder值 = 1.40×10;成人的平均CRing值 = 5.61×10,CRder值 = 2.84×10)比第二次采样活动期间(在C2期间:儿童的平均CRing值 = 1.59×10,CRder值 = 2.54×10;成人的平均CRing值 = 1.02×10,CRder值 = 5.19×10)更高。通过所有采样点计算得出的总致癌风险在第一次采样活动期间很少显示出高至非常高的致癌风险(儿童的平均CRA = 8.73×10,成人的平均CRA = 5.89×10),而在第二次采样活动期间偶尔超过当地居民的安全范围(儿童的平均CRA = 1.59×10,成人的平均CRA = 1.07×10)。