Braun Till, Spiliopoulos Sotirios, Veltman Charlotte, Hergesell Vera, Passow Alexander, Tenderich Gero, Borggrefe Martin, Koerner Michael M
Cardisio GmbH, The Squaire 12, D-60549 Frankfurt am Main, Germany.
Department of Cardiac Surgery, University Heart Center Graz, Medical University Graz, Auenbruggerplatz 29, A-8036 Graz, Austria.
J Electrocardiol. 2020 Mar-Apr;59:100-105. doi: 10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2019.12.018. Epub 2020 Jan 8.
Coronary artery disease (CAD) is a leading cause of death and disability. Conventional non-invasive diagnostic modalities for the detection of stable CAD at rest are subject to significant limitations: low sensitivity, and personal expertise. We aimed to develop a reliable and time-cost efficient screening tool for the detection of coronary ischemia using machine learning.
We developed a supervised artificial intelligence algorithm combined with a five lead vectorcardiography (VCG) approach (i.e. Cardisiography, CSG) for the diagnosis of CAD. Using vectorcardiography, the excitation process of the heart can be described as a three-dimensional signal. A diagnosis can be received, by first, calculating specific physical parameters from the signal, and subsequently, analyzing them with a machine learning algorithm containing neuronal networks. In this multi-center analysis, the primary evaluated outcome was the accuracy of the CSG Diagnosis System, validated by a five-fold nested cross-validation in comparison to angiographic findings as the gold standard. Individuals with 1, 2, or 3- vessel disease were defined as being affected.
Of the 595 patients, 62·0% (n = 369) had 1, 2 or 3- vessel disease identified by coronary angiography. CSG identified a CAD at rest with a sensitivity of 90·2 ± 4·2% for female patients (male: 97·2 ± 3·1%), specificity of 74·4 ± 9·8% (male: 76·1 ± 8·5%), and overall accuracy of 82·5 ± 6·4% (male: 90·7 ± 3·3%).
These findings demonstrate that supervised artificial intelligence-enabled vectorcardiography can overcome limitations of conventional non-invasive diagnostic modalities for the detection of coronary ischemia at rest and is capable as a highly valid screening tool.
冠状动脉疾病(CAD)是导致死亡和残疾的主要原因。用于检测静息状态下稳定CAD的传统非侵入性诊断方法存在显著局限性:灵敏度低且依赖个人专业知识。我们旨在开发一种使用机器学习来检测冠状动脉缺血的可靠且具有时间成本效益的筛查工具。
我们开发了一种结合五导联向量心电图(VCG)方法(即心脏向量图,CSG)的监督式人工智能算法用于CAD的诊断。使用向量心电图,心脏的兴奋过程可以描述为三维信号。首先通过从信号中计算特定物理参数,随后使用包含神经网络的机器学习算法对其进行分析,从而得出诊断结果。在这项多中心分析中,主要评估结果是CSG诊断系统的准确性,通过五重嵌套交叉验证进行验证,并与作为金标准的血管造影结果进行比较。有单支、双支或三支血管病变的个体被定义为患病。
在595例患者中,冠状动脉造影显示62.0%(n = 369)有单支、双支或三支血管病变。CSG检测出静息状态下的CAD,女性患者的灵敏度为90.2±4.2%(男性:97.2±3.1%),特异性为74.4±9.8%(男性:76.1±8.5%),总体准确率为82.5±6.4%(男性:90.7±3.3%)。
这些发现表明,基于监督式人工智能的向量心电图可以克服传统非侵入性诊断方法在检测静息状态下冠状动脉缺血方面的局限性,并且能够作为一种高度有效的筛查工具。