Beier Matthias
1000 W. 42nd St. Indianapolis, IN 46208. E-mail:
Psychoanal Rev. 2020 Feb;107(1):1-34. doi: 10.1521/prev.2020.107.1.1.
In , Freud developed an influential and highly controversial theory for understanding anti-Semitism as blowback against monotheism, specifically against the Jewish people's form of (intellectuality/spirituality) and the notion of exclusive chosenness. Against the backdrop of the recent global rise of anti-Semitism, white supremacy, and violence in the name of religion, this essay reviews a collection of nine fresh perspectives on Freud's text in by authors from a cross section of the humanities. They critically engage Freud's seminal thoughts on the nature of religion and violence, tradition and history, trauma and repression, hermeneutics and the transgenerational transmission of identity. Connecting with Freud's ideas on , the chosen people, the superego, and sublimation, and Drewermann's insights into the historical connection between monotheism and the development of the human sense of personhood, the essay concludes with a proposal for countering anti-Semitism and religious violence through a reinterpretation of the meaning of monotheism.
在[具体年份],弗洛伊德提出了一个有影响力且极具争议的理论,将反犹主义理解为对一神论的反噬,特别是针对犹太民族的[智力/精神层面]形式以及排他性的被选中观念。在近期全球反犹主义、白人至上主义以及以宗教之名实施的暴力行为兴起的背景下,本文回顾了来自人文社科各领域的作者对弗洛伊德[具体文本]的九种全新观点。他们批判性地探讨了弗洛伊德关于宗教与暴力的本质、传统与历史、创伤与压抑、诠释学以及身份认同的代际传递等开创性思想。本文结合弗洛伊德关于[具体内容]、被选中的民族、超我和升华的观点,以及德鲁尔曼对一神论与人类人格意识发展之间历史联系的见解,最后提出通过重新诠释一神论的意义来对抗反犹主义和宗教暴力的建议。