Dainton Christopher, Chu Charlene H
Grand River Hospital, 835 King St. West, Kitchener, ON N2G 1G3, Canada.
Michael G. DeGroote School of Medicine, McMaster University, 10-B Victoria Street South, 3rd Floor Kitchener, ON N2G 1C3, Canada.
Int Health. 2022 Jul 1;14(4):434-441. doi: 10.1093/inthealth/ihz109.
Women's health conditions are commonly encountered on short-term medical missions (STMMs) in Latin America and the Caribbean. There have been no previous attempts to describe women's health protocols used by volunteer clinicians. This qualitative study aimed to describe areas of agreement between unpublished women's health protocols from different North American STMM organizations and assess their concordance with published WHO guidelines.
A systematic web search was used to identify North American STMM sending organizations. Clinical protocols were downloaded from their websites and organizations were contacted to request protocols that were not published online. The protocols obtained were summarized, analysed thematically and compared to existing WHO guidelines.
Of 225 organizations contacted, 112 (49.8%) responded and 31 of these (27.7%) had clinical protocols, of which 20 were obtained and analysed. Nine (45%) discussed sexually transmitted infections, six (30%) discussed pelvic inflammatory disease, two (10%) discussed prenatal care and two (10%) discussed menstrual disorders. None were the product of systematic literature searches and most were not referenced.
To avoid ineffective treatment and related harms to women, volunteer clinicians would benefit from the adaptation and distribution of guidelines for STMMs that are based on existing WHO guidance and acceptable to clinicians, patients and organizations.
在拉丁美洲和加勒比地区的短期医疗任务(STMM)中,女性健康状况很常见。此前尚无尝试描述志愿者临床医生使用的女性健康诊疗方案。这项定性研究旨在描述不同北美短期医疗任务组织未发表的女性健康诊疗方案之间的共识领域,并评估其与世界卫生组织(WHO)已发表指南的一致性。
通过系统的网络搜索来识别北美短期医疗任务派遣组织。从其网站下载临床诊疗方案,并联系各组织索要未在线发表的诊疗方案。对获得的诊疗方案进行总结、主题分析,并与现有的WHO指南进行比较。
在联系的225个组织中,112个(49.8%)做出了回应,其中31个(27.7%)有临床诊疗方案,获得并分析了其中20个。9个(45%)讨论了性传播感染,6个(30%)讨论了盆腔炎,2个(10%)讨论了产前护理,2个(10%)讨论了月经紊乱。没有一个是系统文献检索的产物,且大多数未列出参考文献。
为避免对女性的无效治疗及相关危害,志愿者临床医生将受益于根据现有WHO指南制定、临床医生、患者和组织均可接受的短期医疗任务指南的改编和分发。