Cardiomyopathy Unit, Careggi University Hospital, Florence, Italy.
Department of Experimental and Clinical Medicine, University of Florence, Florence, Italy.
Cardiovasc Drugs Ther. 2020 Apr;34(2):241-253. doi: 10.1007/s10557-020-06948-4.
As the price of next-generation sequencing keeps decreasing, cost is becoming a less important discriminator for diagnostic laboratories in choosing the preferred type of approach to genetic testing. Genome-wide sequencing strategies will plausibly become the standard first-tier tools for genetic testing, with the potential for deeper understanding of the genetic architecture of cardiomyopathies and discovery of the underlying aetiology in the many patients in whom the genetic cause remains elusive. Routine usage of extended sequencing assays will also enable "genetic-first diagnostics", particularly for those patients affected with syndromic conditions of unclear genetic origin, often resulting in costly and distressing diagnostic odysseys before reaching a diagnosis. However, access to genome-wide data for all patients will need to be managed with rigour and caution by (cardiovascular) genetic professionals to avoid erroneous variant pathogenicity assertions and over-reporting uncertain findings, both damaging scenarios to patients and their family members. Researchers will also be required to adopt robust methods to demonstrate novel genetic associations with disease, given the high "narrative potential" of such large datasets and the dangers of generating further false positive associations (that have previously blighted the field of cardiac genetics). Here, we discuss advantages and dangers associated with the routine adoption of whole-exome (and whole-genome) sequencing in diagnostic facilities and in the research setting in the context of cardiomyopathies but relevant to several other conditions.
随着下一代测序技术的价格不断降低,成本对于诊断实验室选择基因检测首选方法的重要性越来越小。全基因组测序策略很可能成为基因检测的标准一线工具,有望更深入地了解心肌病的遗传结构,并发现许多遗传原因仍不明确的患者的潜在病因。扩展测序检测的常规使用也将实现“基于遗传的诊断”,特别是对于那些受不明遗传来源的综合征影响的患者,在得出诊断之前,他们经常经历昂贵且令人痛苦的诊断探索之旅。然而,(心血管)遗传专家需要严格谨慎地管理所有患者的全基因组数据,以避免错误的变异致病性断言和不确定发现的过度报告,这两种情况对患者及其家庭成员都有损害。鉴于此类大型数据集具有很高的“叙事潜力”,并且存在产生更多假阳性关联的危险(此前曾使心脏遗传学领域陷入困境),研究人员还需要采用可靠的方法来证明与疾病相关的新的遗传关联。在这里,我们讨论了在心肌病以及其他几种情况下,在诊断设施和研究环境中常规采用外显子组(和全基因组)测序的优点和危险。