L.B. McCullough is professor of obstetrics and gynecology, Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Hempstead, New York, and ethics scholar, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, New York. J.H. Coverdale is professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences and of medical ethics, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas. F.A. Chervenak is professor and chair, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, and associate dean for international education, Zucker School of Medicine at Hofstra/Northwell, Hempstead, New York, and chair, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York, New York.
Acad Med. 2020 Jun;95(6):828-832. doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000003248.
Trustworthiness is the cornerstone professional virtue in the practice of medicine. The authors' goals for this Invited Commentary were to provide an account of the professional virtue of trustworthiness and its historical origins as well as to suggest how trustworthiness in a professional curriculum can be taught and assessed. They identified 2 components of trustworthiness that originate in the work of John Gregory (1724-1773) and Thomas Percival (1740-1804), who invented the ethical concept of medicine as a profession. The first is intellectual trust, the commitment to scientific and clinical excellence. The second is moral trust, the primary commitment of physicians and health care organizations to promote and protect the interest of patients while keeping individual and group interests secondary. Teaching should focus first on the mastery and understanding of the conceptual vocabulary of intellectual and moral trust through a range of formats, including modeling by faculty on how they respect and treat patients and learners. Assessment should be behaviorally based and articulated in increasing, observable, and integrated levels of mastery through training. Medical educators and academic leaders also share the responsibility to inculcate and sustain an organizational culture of professionalism that is respectful, critically self-appraising, accountable, and committed to its learners and to the promotion of physician well-being. These proposals can be used by medical educators and academic leaders to assist learners to become and remain trustworthy physicians.
诚信是医学实践中至关重要的职业操守。作者撰写这篇特邀评论的目的是阐述诚信这一职业操守及其历史渊源,并提出如何在专业课程中教授和评估诚信。他们确定了诚信的两个组成部分,这两个部分源于约翰·格雷戈里(John Gregory,1724-1773 年)和托马斯·珀西瓦尔(Thomas Percival,1740-1804 年)的著作,他们发明了医学作为一种职业的伦理概念。第一部分是知识诚信,致力于科学和临床卓越。第二部分是道德诚信,是医生和医疗机构的主要承诺,即促进和保护患者利益,同时将个人和团体利益置于次要地位。教学应首先注重通过多种形式掌握和理解知识和道德诚信的概念词汇,包括教师如何尊重和对待患者和学习者的示范。评估应基于行为,并通过培训以可观察到的、不断提高的、综合的掌握水平来明确表达。医学教育工作者和学术领导者也有责任灌输和维持一种尊重、自我批判、负责任、致力于学习者和促进医生福祉的专业文化。这些建议可被医学教育工作者和学术领导者用于帮助学习者成为和保持值得信赖的医生。