Bukowiecki Josephine, Rose Till, Ehlers Ralph, Kage Henning
Institute of Crop Science and Plant Breeding, Christian-Albrechts-University, Kiel, Germany.
Front Plant Sci. 2020 Feb 14;10:1798. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2019.01798. eCollection 2019.
In recent decades, the interest has grown to quantify the green area index as one of the key characteristics of crop canopies (e.g. for modelling transpiration, light interception, growth). The approach of estimating green area index based on multispectral reflection data from unmanned airborne vehicles with lightweight sensors might have the potential to deliver data with sufficient accuracy and high throughput during the whole season.
We therefore examined the applicability of a recently launched drone-based multispectral system (Sequoia, Parrot) for the prediction of whole season green area index in winter wheat, with data from field trials in Northern Germany (2017, 2018 and 2019). The explanatory power of different modeling approaches to predict green area index based on multispectral data was tested: linear and non-linear regression models, multivariate techniques, and machine learning algorithms. Further, different predictors were implemented in these models: multispectral data as raw bands and as ratios. Additionally, a new approach for the evaluation of green area index predictions during senescence is introduced. It is shown that a robust calibration during growth phase is applicable during senescence as well.
A linear model which includes all four wavebands provided by the sensor in three ratios (VIQUO) and a Support Vector Machine (SVM) algorithm allow a reliable and sufficiently accurate whole season prediction. The VIQUO-model is recommended as the best model, as it is precise but still relatively simple, thus easier to communicate and to apply than the SVM. The integrated values of predicted green area indices in an independent trial are highly correlated with their final biomass (R: VIQUO = 0.84, SVM = 0.85) which represents the process of radiation interception, one of the determining factors of growths. This is an indicator for both, a robust model calibration and a high potential of the tested multispectral system for agricultural research and crop management.
近几十年来,人们越来越关注将叶面积指数量化为作物冠层的关键特征之一(例如用于模拟蒸腾作用、光截获、生长)。基于配备轻型传感器的无人机多光谱反射数据估算叶面积指数的方法,有可能在整个季节提供足够准确且高通量的数据。
因此,我们利用德国北部田间试验(2017年、2018年和2019年)的数据,研究了最近推出的基于无人机的多光谱系统(红杉,派诺特)在预测冬小麦全季叶面积指数方面的适用性。测试了基于多光谱数据预测叶面积指数的不同建模方法的解释力:线性和非线性回归模型、多元技术以及机器学习算法。此外,在这些模型中采用了不同的预测变量:作为原始波段和比值的多光谱数据。另外,引入了一种评估衰老期叶面积指数预测的新方法。结果表明,生长阶段的稳健校准在衰老期也适用。
一个包含传感器提供的所有四个波段以三种比值(VIQUO)的线性模型和支持向量机(SVM)算法能够进行可靠且足够准确的全季预测。推荐VIQUO模型作为最佳模型,因为它精确但仍相对简单,因此比SVM更易于交流和应用。在一项独立试验中预测的叶面积指数的综合值与它们的最终生物量高度相关(R:VIQUO = 0.84,SVM = 0.85),这代表了辐射截获过程,而辐射截获是生长的决定因素之一。这既是模型稳健校准的指标,也是所测试的多光谱系统在农业研究和作物管理方面具有高潜力的指标。