Lu Ning, Wang Wenhui, Zhang Qiaofeng, Li Dong, Yao Xia, Tian Yongchao, Zhu Yan, Cao Weixing, Baret Fred, Liu Shouyang, Cheng Tao
National Engineering and Technology Center for Information Agriculture (NETCIA), MARA Key Laboratory for Crop System Analysis and Decision Making, Jiangsu Key Laboratory for Information Agriculture, Jiangsu Collaborative Innovation Center for Modern Crop Production, Institute of Smart Agriculture, Nanjing Agricultural University, Nanjing, China.
UMR EMMAH, INRA, UAPV, Avignon, France.
Front Plant Sci. 2019 Dec 6;10:1601. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2019.01601. eCollection 2019.
Rapid, non-destructive and accurate detection of crop N status is beneficial for optimized fertilizer applications and grain quality prediction in the context of precision crop management. Previous research on the remote estimation of crop N nutrition status was mostly conducted with ground-based spectral data from nadir or oblique angles. Few studies investigated the performance of unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) based multispectral imagery in regular nadir views for such a purpose, not to mention the feasibility of oblique or multi-angular images for improved estimation. This study employed a UAV-based five-band camera to acquire multispectral images at seven view zenith angles (VZAs) (0°, ± 20°, ± 40° and ±60°) for three critical growth stages of winter wheat. Four representative vegetation indices encompassing the Visible Atmospherically Resistant Index (VARI), Red edge Chlorophyll Index (CI), Green band Chlorophyll Index (CI), Modified Normalized Difference Vegetation Index with a blue band (mND) were derived from the multi-angular images. They were used to estimate the N nutrition status in leaf nitrogen concentration (LNC), plant nitrogen concentration (PNC), leaf nitrogen accumulation (LNA), and plant nitrogen accumulation (PNA) of wheat canopies for a combination of treatments in N rate, variety and planting density. The results demonstrated that the highest accuracy for single-angle images was obtained with CI for LNC from a VZA of -60° ( = 0.71, RMSE = 0.34%) and PNC from a VZA of -40° ( = 0.36, RMSE = 0.29%). When combining an off-nadir image (-40°) and the 0° image, the accuracy of PNC estimation was substantially improved (CI: = 0.52, RMSE = 0.28%). However, the use of dual-angle images did not significantly increase the estimation accuracy for LNA and PNA compared to the use of single-angle images. Our findings suggest that it is important and practical to use oblique images from a UAV-based multispectral camera for better estimation of nitrogen concentration in wheat leaves or plants. The oblique images acquired from additional flights could be used alone or combined with the nadir-view images for improved crop N status monitoring.
在精准作物管理背景下,快速、无损且准确地检测作物氮素状况有利于优化肥料施用和预测谷物品质。以往关于作物氮素营养状况遥感估算的研究大多使用来自天底或倾斜角度的地面光谱数据。很少有研究调查基于无人机的多光谱图像在常规天底视角下用于此目的的性能,更不用说倾斜或多角度图像用于改进估算的可行性了。本研究使用基于无人机的五波段相机,在冬小麦三个关键生长阶段,以七个视顶角(VZA)(0°、±20°、±40°和±60°)获取多光谱图像。从多角度图像中得出了四个代表性植被指数,包括可见大气抗性指数(VARI)、红边叶绿素指数(CI)、绿波段叶绿素指数(CI)、含蓝波段的修正归一化差异植被指数(mND)。它们被用于估算不同施氮量、品种和种植密度组合处理下小麦冠层叶片氮浓度(LNC)、植株氮浓度(PNC)、叶片氮积累量(LNA)和植株氮积累量(PNA)中的氮素营养状况。结果表明,对于单角度图像,从 - 60°的VZA获取的CI对LNC的估算精度最高(R² = 0.71,RMSE = 0.34%),从 - 40°的VZA获取的CI对PNC的估算精度最高(R² = 0.36,RMSE = 0.29%)。当结合一个非天底图像( - 40°)和0°图像时,PNC估算的精度显著提高(CI:R² = 0.52,RMSE = 0.28%)。然而,与使用单角度图像相比,使用双角度图像对LNA和PNA的估算精度并没有显著提高。我们的研究结果表明,使用基于无人机的多光谱相机的倾斜图像来更好地估算小麦叶片或植株中的氮浓度是重要且实用的。从额外飞行获取的倾斜图像可以单独使用,或与天底视角图像结合使用,以改进作物氮素状况监测。