Dempsey Amanda, Kwan Bethany M, Wagner Nicole M, Pyrzanowski Jennifer, Brewer Sarah E, Sevick Carter, Narwaney Komal, Resnicow Kenneth, Glanz Jason
University of Colorado, Denver, Aurora, CO, United States.
Kaiser Permanente Colorado Institute for Health Research, Denver, CO, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2020 Mar 5;22(3):e15800. doi: 10.2196/15800.
Vaccine hesitancy among parents leads to childhood undervaccination and outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease. As the reasons for vaccine hesitancy are diverse, there is often not enough time during regular clinical visits for medical providers to adequately address all the concerns that parents have. Providing individually tailored vaccine information via the internet before a clinical visit may be a good mechanism for effectively allaying parents' vaccination concerns while also being time efficient. Including tailoring based on values is a promising, but untested, approach to message creation.
This study aimed to describe the process by which we developed a Web-based intervention that is being used in an ongoing randomized controlled trial aimed at improving the timeliness of infant vaccination by reducing parental vaccine hesitancy.
Development of the intervention incorporated evidence-based health behavior theories. A series of interviews, surveys, and feedback sessions were used to iteratively develop the intervention in collaboration with vaccination experts and potential end users.
In all, 41 specific content areas were identified to be included in the intervention. User feedback elucidated preferences for specific design elements to be incorporated throughout the website. The tile-based architecture chosen for the website was perceived as easy to use. Creating messages that were two-sided was generally preferred over other message formats. Quantitative surveys identified associations between specific vaccine values and vaccination beliefs, suggesting that values tailoring should vary, depending on the specific belief being endorsed.
Using health behavior theories, qualitative and quantitative data, and significant expert and end user input, we created a novel, Web-based intervention to improve infant vaccination timeliness. The intervention is based on tailoring messages according to each individual's values and beliefs. This intervention is currently being tested in a controlled randomized clinical trial.
父母对疫苗的犹豫导致儿童疫苗接种不足以及疫苗可预防疾病的爆发。由于疫苗犹豫的原因多种多样,在常规临床就诊期间,医疗服务提供者通常没有足够的时间充分解决父母所有的担忧。在临床就诊前通过互联网提供个性化的疫苗信息可能是有效缓解父母疫苗接种担忧同时又节省时间的良好机制。基于价值观进行定制是一种有前景但未经测试的信息创建方法。
本研究旨在描述我们开发基于网络干预措施的过程,该干预措施正在一项正在进行的随机对照试验中使用,旨在通过减少父母对疫苗的犹豫来提高婴儿疫苗接种的及时性。
干预措施的开发纳入了基于证据的健康行为理论。通过一系列访谈、调查和反馈会议,与疫苗接种专家和潜在最终用户合作,反复开发干预措施。
总共确定了41个特定内容领域纳入干预措施。用户反馈阐明了对网站中应纳入的特定设计元素的偏好。为网站选择的基于瓷砖的架构被认为易于使用。与其他信息格式相比,通常更倾向于创建双面信息。定量调查确定了特定疫苗价值观与疫苗接种信念之间的关联,表明价值观定制应根据所支持的特定信念而有所不同。
利用健康行为理论、定性和定量数据以及大量专家和最终用户的意见,我们创建了一种新颖的基于网络的干预措施,以提高婴儿疫苗接种的及时性。该干预措施基于根据每个人的价值观和信念定制信息。目前正在一项对照随机临床试验中对该干预措施进行测试。