Schoeler Natasha E, Simpson Zoe, Whiteley Victoria J, Nguyen Patty, Meskell Rachel, Lightfoot Kathyrn, Martin-McGill Kirsty J, Olpin Simon, Ivison Fiona
UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health London UK.
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children London UK.
Epilepsia Open. 2019 Nov 29;5(1):73-79. doi: 10.1002/epi4.12371. eCollection 2020 Mar.
Biochemical assessment is recommended for patients prior to initiating and following a ketogenic diet (KD). There is no published literature regarding current practice in the UK and Ireland. We aimed to explore practice in comparison with international guidelines, determine approximate costs of biochemical testing in KD patients across the UK and Ireland, and promote greater consistency in KD services nationally.
A survey was designed to determine the biochemical tests requested for patients at baseline, 3, 6, 12, 18, and 24 months + on KD. The survey was circulated to 39 centers across the UK and Ireland.
Sixteen centers completed the survey. Full blood count, electrolytes, calcium, liver function tests (LFTs), lipid profile, and vitamin D were requested at all centers at baseline, in keeping with international guidelines. Bicarbonate, total protein, and urinalysis were less consistently requested. Magnesium and zinc were requested by all centers, despite not being specifically recommended for pre-diet evaluation in guidelines. Urea and electrolyte profiles and some LFTs were consistently requested at follow-up, in accordance with guidelines. Other LFTs and renal tests, full blood count, lipid profile, acylcarnitine profile, selenium, vitamin D, and urinalysis were less consistently requested at follow-up. The mean costs of the lowest and highest number of tests requested at baseline in our participating centers were £167.54 and £501.93; the mean costs of the lowest and highest number of tests requested at 3-month follow-up were £19.17 and £450.06.
Biochemical monitoring of KD patients varies widely across the UK and Ireland and does not fully correspond to international best practice guidelines. With an ongoing drive for cost-effectiveness within health care, further work is needed to streamline practice while ensuring patient safety.
建议在开始生酮饮食(KD)及后续过程中对患者进行生化评估。目前尚无关于英国和爱尔兰当前实践情况的公开文献。我们旨在探讨与国际指南相比的实践情况,确定英国和爱尔兰KD患者生化检测的大致费用,并在全国范围内促进KD服务的更大一致性。
设计了一项调查,以确定在KD基线、3、6、12、18和24个月及以后为患者进行的生化检测项目。该调查在英国和爱尔兰的39个中心进行。
16个中心完成了调查。所有中心在基线时均要求进行全血细胞计数、电解质、钙、肝功能检查(LFTs)、血脂谱和维生素D检测,这与国际指南一致。碳酸氢盐、总蛋白和尿液分析的要求不太一致。尽管指南中未特别推荐在饮食前评估中检测镁和锌,但所有中心都进行了检测。根据指南,在随访时始终要求进行尿素和电解质检测以及一些肝功能检查。其他肝功能检查和肾脏检测、全血细胞计数、血脂谱、酰基肉碱谱、硒、维生素D和尿液分析在随访时的要求不太一致。我们参与调查的中心在基线时要求进行的最低和最高检测次数的平均费用分别为167.54英镑和501.93英镑;在3个月随访时要求进行的最低和最高检测次数的平均费用分别为19.17英镑和450.06英镑。
英国和爱尔兰对KD患者的生化监测差异很大,且与国际最佳实践指南不完全相符。随着医疗保健领域对成本效益的持续追求,需要进一步开展工作以简化实践,同时确保患者安全。