Restorative Dentistry Department, King Abdulaziz University Faculty of Dentistry, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
Department of Medical Education, University of Illinois College of Medicine at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
J Dent Educ. 2020 Jul;84(7):812-829. doi: 10.1002/jdd.12138. Epub 2020 Mar 8.
The primary aim of this review was to synthesize the literature for studies investigating the use of computer simulation (CS) and virtual reality (VR) in undergraduate dental education in operative and restorative dentistry. The secondary aim was to list best practices that maximize the simulation experience in dental education. A literature review of the PubMed and ERIC databases was conducted using the search terms "Dental AND Simulator," "Dental AND Virtual reality," and "Simulation AND Dental education." Studies in English language were categorized into 1 of 5 themes: Manual dexterity and cavity preparation, light curing skills, simulation perception and experience, predictability, and simulation model development. Main practices of simulation education indicated in the McGaghie et al. critical review published in 2010 were used as a reference to identify common practices for dental simulation. Thirty nine of 579 identified abstracts met the inclusion criteria. Skill acquisition and feedback were the two most frequently investigated parameters found in the review. CS was efficient in teaching cavity preparation and light curing skills. Feedback and deliberate practice were among the best practices that should be emphasized in order to enhance the efficiency of the CS and VR simulation exercises. The use of CS is effective in teaching operative skills (such as light curing and cavity preparation) reliably; whereas, the use of VR in undergraduate curricula is debatable. To achieve the maximum benefits of the simulation exercises, emphasis must be given to the timely feedback and deliberate practice approaches.
本次综述的主要目的是综合研究计算机模拟(CS)和虚拟现实(VR)在口腔操作和修复学本科教学中应用的文献。次要目的是列出最大限度地提高牙科教育中模拟体验的最佳实践。使用“牙科和模拟器”、“牙科和虚拟现实”和“模拟和牙科教育”这三个检索词,对 PubMed 和 ERIC 数据库进行了文献回顾。研究均为英文,分为以下 5 个主题之一:手工灵巧性和窝洞预备、光固化技能、模拟感知和体验、可预测性和模拟模型开发。2010 年 McGaghie 等人发表的关键评论中提到的模拟教育的主要实践被用作参考,以确定牙科模拟的常见实践。在 579 篇摘要中,有 39 篇符合纳入标准。技能获取和反馈是该综述中发现的两个最常被调查的参数。CS 在教授窝洞预备和光固化技能方面非常有效。反馈和刻意练习是增强 CS 和 VR 模拟练习效率的最佳实践之一。CS 在教授操作性技能(如光固化和窝洞预备)方面非常有效;而在本科课程中使用 VR 则存在争议。为了充分利用模拟练习的好处,必须重视及时反馈和刻意练习方法。