President's Office - Regional Administration and Local Government (Directorate of Health, Social Welfare and Nutrition Services), P.O Box 1923, Dodoma, Tanzania.
Program in Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Mar 17;20(1):218. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-5057-2.
Infrastructure development and upgrading to support safe surgical services in primary health care facilities is an important step in the journey towards achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC). Quality health service provision together with equitable geographic access and service delivery are important components that constitute UHC. Tanzania has been investing in infrastructure development to offer essential safe surgery close to communities at affordable costs while ensuring better outcomes. This study aimed to understand the public sector's efforts to improve the infrastructure of primary health facilities between 2005 and 2019. We assessed the construction rates, geographic coverage, and physical status of each facility, surgical safety and services rendered in public primary health facilities.
Data was collected from existing policy reports, the Services Availability and Readiness Assessment (SARA) tool (physical status), the Health Facility Registry (HFR), implementation reports on infrastructure development from the 26 regions and 185 district councils across the country (covering assessment of physical infrastructure, waste management systems and inventories for ambulances) and Comprehensive Emergence Obstetric Care (CEMONC) signal functions assessment tool. Data was descriptively analyzed so as to understand the distribution of primary health care facilities and their status (old, new, upgraded, under construction, renovated and equipped), and the service provided, including essential surgical services.
Of 5072 (518 are Health Centers and 4554 are Dispensaries) existing public primary health care facilities, the majority (46%) had a physical status of A (good state), 33% (1693) had physical status of B (minor renovation needed) and the remaining facilities had physical status of C up to F (needing major renovation). About 33% (1673) of all health facilities had piped water and 5.1% had landline telecommunication system. Between 2015 and August 2019, a total of 419 (8.3%) health facilities (Consisting of 350 health centers and 69 District Council Hospitals) were either renovated or constructed and equipped to offer safe surgery services. Of all Health Centers only 115 (22.2%) were offering the CEMONC services. Of these 115 health facilities, only 20 (17.4%) were offering the CEMONC services with all 9 - signal functions and only 17.4% had facilities that are offering safe blood transfusion services.
This study indicates that between 2015 and 2019 there has been improvement in physical status of primary health facilities as a result constructions, upgrading and equipping the facilities to offer safe surgery and related diagnostic services. Despite the achievements, still there is a high demand for good physical statuses and functioning of primary health facilities with capacity to offer essential and safe surgical services in the country also as an important strategy towards achieving UHC. This is also inline with the National Surgical, Obstetrics and Anesthesia plan (NSOAP).
在初级卫生保健设施中支持安全手术服务的基础设施发展和升级是实现全民健康覆盖(UHC)的重要步骤。提供高质量的卫生服务以及公平的地理可及性和服务提供是构成 UHC 的重要组成部分。坦桑尼亚一直在投资基础设施建设,以便以可负担的成本在社区附近提供基本的安全手术,同时确保更好的结果。本研究旨在了解 2005 年至 2019 年期间公共部门为改善初级卫生设施基础设施所做的努力。我们评估了每个设施的建设率、地理覆盖范围和物理状况、公共初级卫生设施中的手术安全性和提供的服务。
数据来自现有政策报告、服务可用性和准备情况评估 (SARA) 工具(物理状况)、卫生设施登记册 (HFR)、全国 26 个地区和 185 个区议会的基础设施发展实施报告(涵盖对物理基础设施、废物管理系统和救护车库存的评估)以及综合紧急产科护理 (CEMONC) 信号功能评估工具。对数据进行描述性分析,以了解初级卫生保健设施的分布及其状况(旧、新、升级、在建、翻新和设备齐全),以及提供的服务,包括基本手术服务。
在现有的 5072 个(518 个是卫生中心,4554 个是诊所)公共初级卫生保健设施中,大多数(46%)设施的物理状况为 A(良好状态),33%(1693 个)设施的物理状况为 B(需要进行小修),其余设施的物理状况为 C 至 F(需要大修)。大约 33%(1673 个)的所有卫生设施都有管道供水,5.1%的设施有固定电话通信系统。2015 年至 2019 年 8 月期间,共有 419 个(包括 350 个卫生中心和 69 个区议会医院)卫生设施进行了翻新或建设和设备齐全,以提供安全手术服务。在所有卫生中心中,只有 115 个(22.2%)提供 CEMONC 服务。在这 115 个卫生设施中,只有 20 个(17.4%)提供 CEMONC 服务,提供了所有 9 个信号功能,只有 17.4%的设施提供安全输血服务。
本研究表明,2015 年至 2019 年间,由于对卫生设施进行了建设、升级和设备配备,以提供安全手术和相关诊断服务,初级卫生保健设施的物理状况得到了改善。尽管取得了这些成就,但仍有很大的需求是改善初级卫生设施的物理状况和功能,使其具备提供基本和安全手术服务的能力,这也是实现全民健康覆盖的一项重要战略。这也符合国家外科、产科和麻醉计划 (NSOAP)。