Cerezo Alison, Cummings Mariah, Holmes Meredith, Williams Chelsey
University of California Santa Barbara, CA, USA.
San Francisco State University, CA, USA.
Psychol Women Q. 2020 Mar;44(1):67-83. doi: 10.1177/0361684319875977. Epub 2019 Sep 30.
Although the concept of intersectionality has gained widespread attention in psychological research, there remains a significant gap related to the impact of intersectionality on identity formation for persons negotiating multiple minority statuses. This gap is especially pronounced among sexual and gender expansive women of Latinx and African American descent-two groups that face disparate personal and public health risks but are largely ignored in the research literature. In response to this gap, we carried out a qualitative study using constructivist grounded theory with 20 Latinx and African American sexual minority, gender expansive women to understand participants' experiences of forming an intersectional social identity. Following an exploration of identity formation related to the specific domains of race, gender identity, and sexual orientation, we prompted participants to consider how each of the specified identity domains impacted the formation and experience of an overall intersectional identity (e.g., how racial position impacted gender identity and/or sexual identity formation). Findings revealed four major themes that were critical in identity formation: (a) family and cultural expectations, (b) freedom to explore identity, (c) the constant negotiation of insider/outsider status, and (d) identity integration as an act of resistance. Implications for future research and psychological services are discussed.
尽管交叉性概念在心理学研究中已获得广泛关注,但在交叉性对那些兼具多种少数群体身份的人的身份形成的影响方面,仍存在重大差距。这种差距在拉丁裔和非裔美国裔的性取向和性别认同多元的女性中尤为明显——这两个群体面临着不同的个人和公共健康风险,但在研究文献中基本被忽视。针对这一差距,我们采用建构主义扎根理论对20名拉丁裔和非裔美国裔性少数、性别认同多元的女性进行了一项定性研究,以了解参与者形成交叉社会身份的经历。在探索了与种族、性别认同和性取向等特定领域相关的身份形成之后,我们促使参与者思考每个指定的身份领域如何影响整体交叉身份的形成和体验(例如,种族地位如何影响性别认同和/或性身份形成)。研究结果揭示了身份形成中至关重要的四个主要主题:(a)家庭和文化期望,(b)探索身份的自由,(c)内部人/外部人身份的持续协商,以及(d)作为一种抵抗行为的身份整合。文中还讨论了对未来研究和心理服务的启示。