Chesi P, Marini M G, Mancardi G L, Patti F, Alivernini L, Bisecco A, Borriello G, Bucello S, Caleri F, Cavalla P, Cocco E, Cordioli C, Di Giuseppe M, Fantozzi R, Gattuso M, Granella F, Liguori M, Locatelli L, Lugaresi A, Marangoni S, Moiola L, Mutta E, Neri W, Pastò L, Perini P, Petruzzo M, Plewnia K, Repice A M, Rezzonico M, Romano S, Rovaris M, Sessa E, Tortorella C, Totaro R, Valentino P
Health Care and Wellbeing Area, Fondazione ISTUD, Milan, Italy.
Department of Neuroscience, Rehabilitation, Ophthalmology, Genetics, Maternal and Child Health, University of Genova and Scientific Clinical Institutes Maugeri IRCCS, Pavia-Genova Nervi, Genova, Italy.
Neurol Sci. 2020 Aug;41(8):2231-2240. doi: 10.1007/s10072-020-04301-z. Epub 2020 Mar 20.
Aim of the research was to define the quality of life of Italian neurologists and nurses' professional caring for multiple sclerosis, to understand their living the clinical practice and identify possible signals of compassion fatigue.
One hundred five neurologists and nurses from 30 Italian multiple sclerosis centres were involved in an online quali-quantitative survey on the organization of care, combined with the Satisfaction and Compassion Fatigue Test and a collection of narratives. Descriptive statistics of the quantitative data were integrated with the results obtained by the narrative medicine methods of analysis.
Most of the practitioners were neurologists, 46 average years old, 69% women, 43% part time dedicated to multiple sclerosis. An increased number of patients in the last 3 years were referred in 29 centres. Differences were found between neurologists and nurses. Physicians showed higher risks of burnout, reporting intensive working paces, lack of medical personnel, and anxiety caused by the precarious employment conditions. Nurses appeared more satisfied, although the reference to the lack of spaces, and the cross professional roles risk of compassion fatigue. Both positive and negative relationships of care were depicted as influencing the professional quality of life.
The interviewed neurological teams need to limit the risk of compassion fatigue, which appeared from the first years of the career. The prevalence of the risk among neurologists suggests more awareness among scientific societies and health care managers on the risk for this category, as first step to prevent it.
本研究旨在确定意大利神经科医生和护士对多发性硬化症患者的专业护理质量,了解他们的临床实践情况,并识别可能出现的同情疲劳迹象。
来自意大利30个多发性硬化症中心的105名神经科医生和护士参与了一项关于护理组织的在线定性和定量调查,同时进行了满意度和同情疲劳测试以及叙事收集。定量数据的描述性统计与通过叙事医学分析方法获得的结果相结合。
大多数从业者是神经科医生,平均年龄46岁,69%为女性,43%兼职从事多发性硬化症相关工作。在29个中心,过去3年转诊的患者数量有所增加。神经科医生和护士之间存在差异。医生表现出更高的职业倦怠风险,报告称工作节奏紧张、医务人员短缺以及不稳定的就业条件导致焦虑。护士似乎更满意,但提到空间不足以及跨专业角色存在同情疲劳风险。护理中的积极和消极关系都被描述为影响职业生活质量。
接受采访的神经科团队需要降低同情疲劳的风险,这种风险在职业生涯的最初几年就已出现。神经科医生中这种风险的普遍性表明,科学协会和医疗保健管理者应提高对这一群体风险的认识,作为预防的第一步。