Department of Behavioural Science and Health, University College London, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2020 Mar 25;15(3):e0230487. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0230487. eCollection 2020.
Participation in the arts has well-documented benefits for health. However, participation in the arts is socially patterned, and it remains unclear why this is: what factors act as barriers or enablers of individual arts engagement. Therefore this study explored how individual characteristics predict individuals' capabilities, opportunities and motivations to engage in participatory arts activities.
We analysed data from 6,867 adults in the UK (61.2% female, average age 46.7 years) who engage infrequently in performing arts, visual arts, design and crafts, literature-related activities, or online, digital and electronic arts. We constructed a structural equation model to explore the relationship between demographic factors (including age, sex, ethnicity or socio-economic status), health factors (including physical and mental health) or social factors (including living alone, urban density, loneliness or socialising) and perceived barriers to arts engagement.
Individuals with poorer physical and mental health experienced more barriers affecting their perceived capabilities to engage in the arts, whilst individuals with poorer mental health also described experiencing more barriers affecting their motivations to engage. Individuals of lower SES reported more barriers in terms of opportunities to engage, whilst loneliness was related to more barriers around opportunities and motivations and living alone was associated with more opportunity barriers. Interestingly, adults who were older experienced fewer barriers relating to capabilities or opportunities, as did men, whilst being of white ethnicity was associated with fewer barriers across all three domains. Adults who were more socially engaged or who had poorer physical health experienced fewer barriers relating to motivations. Geographical area of dwelling was not related to any barriers.
This study has shown for the first time where the barriers leading to differential patterns of arts engagement lie. The findings could inform future behaviour change interventions designed to encourage arts engagement amongst individuals who are least likely to engage.
参与艺术活动对健康有良好的益处。然而,参与艺术活动具有明显的社会模式,其原因尚不清楚:是什么因素阻碍或促进了个人参与艺术活动。因此,本研究探讨了个体特征如何预测个人参与参与性艺术活动的能力、机会和动机。
我们分析了来自英国的 6867 名成年人的数据(女性占 61.2%,平均年龄 46.7 岁),他们偶尔参与表演艺术、视觉艺术、设计和手工艺、文学相关活动或在线、数字和电子艺术。我们构建了一个结构方程模型,以探讨人口统计学因素(包括年龄、性别、种族或社会经济地位)、健康因素(包括身心健康)或社会因素(包括独居、城市密度、孤独或社交)与参与艺术活动的感知障碍之间的关系。
身心健康状况较差的个体经历了更多影响其参与艺术活动能力的感知障碍,而心理健康状况较差的个体也描述了更多影响其参与动机的感知障碍。社会经济地位较低的个体在参与机会方面报告了更多的障碍,而孤独感与机会和动机方面的更多障碍以及独居与更多的机会障碍有关。有趣的是,年龄较大的成年人在能力或机会方面的障碍较少,男性也是如此,而白人种族在所有三个领域的障碍都较少。社交参与度较高或身体健康状况较差的成年人在与动机相关的障碍较少。居住的地理区域与任何障碍都没有关系。
本研究首次展示了导致不同艺术参与模式的障碍所在。这些发现可以为未来旨在鼓励最不可能参与艺术活动的个体参与艺术活动的行为改变干预措施提供信息。