Department of Oncology, Section of Radiotherapy, Rigshospitalet, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Niels Bohr Institute, Faculty of Science, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Acta Oncol. 2020 Aug;59(8):879-887. doi: 10.1080/0284186X.2020.1733654. Epub 2020 Mar 27.
In current radiotherapy (RT) planning and delivery, population-based dose-volume constraints are used to limit the risk of toxicity from incidental irradiation of organs at risks (OARs). However, weighing tradeoffs between target coverage and doses to OARs (or prioritizing different OARs) in a quantitative way for each patient is challenging. We introduce a novel RT planning approach for patients with mediastinal Hodgkin lymphoma (HL) that aims to maximize overall outcome for each patient by optimizing on tumor control and mortality from late effects simultaneously. We retrospectively analyzed 34 HL patients treated with conformal RT (3DCRT). We used published data to model recurrence and radiation-induced mortality from coronary heart disease and secondary lung and breast cancers. Patient-specific doses to the heart, lung, breast, and target were incorporated in the models as well as age, sex, and cardiac risk factors (CRFs). A preliminary plan of candidate beams was created for each patient in a commercial treatment planning system. From these candidate beams, outcome-optimized (O-OPT) plans for each patient were created with an in-house optimization code that minimized the individual risk of recurrence and mortality from late effects. O-OPT plans were compared to VMAT plans and clinical 3DCRT plans. O-OPT plans generally had the lowest risk, followed by the clinical 3DCRT plans, then the VMAT plans with the highest risk with median (maximum) total risk values of 4.9 (11.1), 5.1 (17.7), and 7.6 (20.3)%, respectively (no CRFs). Compared to clinical 3DCRT plans, O-OPT planning reduced the total risk by at least 1% for 9/34 cases assuming no CRFs and 11/34 cases assuming presence of CRFs. We developed an individualized, outcome-optimized planning technique for HL. Some of the resulting plans were substantially different from clinical plans. The results varied depending on how risk models were defined or prioritized.
在当前的放射治疗(RT)计划和实施中,使用基于人群的剂量-体积限制来限制因照射风险器官(OAR)而导致毒性的风险。然而,对于每个患者,以定量的方式权衡目标覆盖和 OAR 剂量之间的权衡(或对不同的 OAR 进行优先级排序)是具有挑战性的。我们为纵隔霍奇金淋巴瘤(HL)患者引入了一种新的 RT 计划方法,旨在通过同时优化肿瘤控制和晚期效应导致的死亡率,为每个患者实现最佳的总体结果。我们回顾性分析了 34 例接受适形 RT(3DCRT)治疗的 HL 患者。我们使用已发表的数据来模拟复发和由冠心病以及继发性肺和乳腺癌引起的放射诱导死亡率。将患者特异性的心脏、肺、乳房和靶区剂量以及年龄、性别和心脏危险因素(CRF)纳入模型中。为每位患者在商业治疗计划系统中创建了候选射束的初步计划。从这些候选射束中,使用内部优化代码为每位患者创建了结果优化(O-OPT)计划,该计划最小化了个体因晚期效应而复发和死亡的风险。将 O-OPT 计划与 VMAT 计划和临床 3DCRT 计划进行比较。O-OPT 计划通常风险最低,其次是临床 3DCRT 计划,然后是 VMAT 计划,风险最高,中位数(最大值)总风险值分别为 4.9(11.1)、5.1(17.7)和 7.6(20.3)%(无 CRF)。与临床 3DCRT 计划相比,假设无 CRF,则 O-OPT 计划可将 9/34 例患者的总风险降低至少 1%,假设存在 CRF,则 11/34 例患者的总风险降低至少 1%。我们为 HL 开发了一种个体化、结果优化的规划技术。一些结果计划与临床计划有很大不同。结果因风险模型的定义或优先级而异而有所不同。